Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza

Very solid pie, but could be better. It was like someone combined an arcade/bar pie with a NY pizza, but in a good way. Unfortunatly, our pie could have been cooked longer and probably would have brought it to an 8.5. Still one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time.

Solid pie! Very good cheese, tasty sauce. Good crunch and very little flop. Will be back!

Levi said very cheesy!

Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushroom and extra cheese. Very yummy! Great crisp on crust. Delicious toppings. Came to table way too hot to eat and toppings slid off the first slice but after letting it cool just a bit it was excellent!

Excellent pie. Excellent service. Good char underneath. Juicy pepperoni and good amount of grease pools on top 👍👍

Toby’s pizza is consistently good. “NYC”/deck style so the pies are large. Crust on the thinner side a little bit of flop. Decent tomato base and tang. Not afraid of cheese. Always busy so your pizza and food will be hot and fresh. Side note: their Philly cheese steak is phenomenal.

Tried the cheesesteak, plain slice, and pep. All very good! Great flavor sauce on the pie, nice fresh and tasty all around.

Very good pizza! Slightly more well done would make a huge difference

Good pie, we enjoyed it.

Fantastic. Great under-carriage, slight char, no flop. Thin crust, perfect ratio of sauce and cheese.

Good pizza

A solid pie. Cheese and sauce was good and the under carriage was a bit floppy but still decent. it’s a pretty thin pizza so if that’s your style you’ll like it

Toby knows what he is doing. Amazing pies & lethal garlic knots. Also, for the people who care, they have Poppin Pink Lemonade. Must try if you live in Tampa Bay!

Not the best but far from the worst. The kids like the pizza and loved the garlic rolls. For me it’s a solid slice.

This pizza was worse than I expected after seeing the Prez and community reviews. I found it to be super meh. Just a step above Joey Brooklyns 🤢. Oily, floppy all the way to the crust, undercarriage had no crunch, crust was good, sauce is not unique from the next pizza shop, the pepperoni is good quality. I’ll stick to my normal shop that the Prez hasn’t hit yet.

Solid NY pizza

Not sure what Dave is talking about. (Midder than mid) White pizza with Ricotta & the Cheesesteaks were better.

It really is as about as close to a NY pizza as you’re going to get outside of the northeast.

Decent pizza way too much sauce to cheese ratio