Tomasino's Pizza - Lake Mary

As a northern transplant, I miss Papa Gino's Pizza. This pizza is the closest thing I can find in Florida to Papa Gino's.

Quality ingredients, quality pizza. They have a good lunch deal and a huge selection of slices. Will definitely be back.

Ok thought the cheese and sauce went well together the pepperoni was really good and the crust was cooked exactly the way it should be. Bottom was well done but not burnt. Had a good bit of flavor and had no flop. It was very greasy but I’m still going o give it a 7.6 it ranks with best I’ve had in Florida so far.

Rookie score but that’s what it is. Thin and greasy but good flavor. Your local pizza shop

This is about as good as it gets for you local delivery standards. I would choose this over other chains. As soon as I bit into it, I was taken aback by how quality the cheese tastes, it doesn’t taste like any other pizza I’ve had before. The sauce was good but underwhelmed by the cheese but it was not bad by any means, I think I may ask for more sauce next time (personal preference). The crust left something to be desired, there was no flavor to it. You can add a buttery Parmesan spread to the crust for $2 but that price seemed a little steep for some spread. Try the bruschetta garlic notes, they were phenomenal.

Cooked well, good undercarriage. A bit greasy. 7.4 compared to pizza around the country but really one of the best in Orlando.

A little greasy but very good. Nothing to drive an hour for but if you’re in the area and want a good pie, this is definitely worth it.

Pizza might be a little on the greasy side, but it has a good undercarriage and little to no flop. Good crunch, great flavor!

Great flavor..I’ve had the regular cheese ..a bit of a flop but the cheese and sauce go great you can taste a hint of garlic

Middle of thr road.

Review will be on the cheese slice. Initial impression is that it looked good but greasy. Before we continue though, I chose the lunch special which means you get slices from pizza prepared an unspecified time earlier. They put it in the oven before giving it to a customer. Not usually my favorite. Definitely some flop and dripping grease. Taste was good and the crust was excellent. This pizzeria is within walking distance of work so I’ll definitely revisit but not good enough to drive more than 5 min for. If it’s in the area give it a try. Good prices. 8 bucks for 2 slices and a salad or drink.

Excellent Pizza. Char in bottom, crispy cust, not too much grease and great sauce. I love their eggplant pizza.

Cheese pie (baseline). Good crisp and not much flop. Sauce doesn’t have much tang. All-in-all its a good pizza. I wouldn’t drive across town, but if it’s close by they’d know who I was.