Tomaso's

Sal’s Pizza Cedarburg, WI Not Tomaso’s Reheated single slice. Might be higher score with fresh pie.

Really good pizza. Crust has great crisp, sauce is delicious, cheese is quality, and the pepperoni is plentiful. Only issue is the last couple times I’ve ordered from here my pizza has had other toppings on it that I hate. This time there were a couple onions and a mushroom mixed in. Has the potential for an easy 8+ score.

I think Dave would like!

Genuinely if you can get this hit and saucy there is no better pizza in the state if Wisconsin. Depends on the amount of sauce put on the pie!!!

Other reviewers don’t understand the scale and are too high. This is conveyor belt pizza which is very decent but there is nothing outstanding about it.

One of the best pizza around. Dining around has a great old time feel to it

Missing somethin’

One of the best bar pies in WI

Not a place I would return to. Crust is way to dry and taste like flour. We had to wait on ourselves as the lady sat behind the bar talking on FaceTime. Everything is sat onto the bar for the customers to come fetch. Pizza 6.6 experience. 4.5.

Give Frankie a spankie cause this one ain’t hitting. The port boys are back and we won’t be quitin. Just listen to this review we bout to be spitting. One of the best reviews to ever be written. No flop. Can’t really taste the cheese. Overpowering seasoning.

First pie with sauce on top, good introduction to this type of pizza. Perfect atmosphere and great sauce.

Cracker crust, cheese on the bottom then their unbelievable secret family sauce, sausage from local company, extra cheese on top! The best I’ve ever had. Been coming here since 1991, even now we live 30 minutes away and come once a week! Try a little Giardiniera ( an Italian zesty topping of peppers,olives,carrots,celery, in olive oil) which is pictured in the jar behind the pizza

Really boring pizza with a weird atmosphere.

Had the deep dish, it was decent. Thin crust looked better

This is a must stop if you are in Cedarburg!