When they make it just right it can’t be beat probably best in the state. That being said they can be a little inconsistent and get some off pies sometimes (over cooked/undercooked or proportions off) overall best place to go for coal fire pizza.
lems195/7/22, 9:01 p.m.
Perfect proportions, delicious thin crisp crust, AMAZING taste overall!! First experience of New Haven style and it did not disappoint. Almost didn’t get a picture because it got eaten so quickly!!!
newjerseydevil7/31/21, 12:07 a.m.
Pretty good. lol greasy on the cheese slice. Cheese quality good and char on point.
cameron.young426/24/21, 12:48 a.m.
Like the pres said, a tiny bit on the floppy side, but as close to new Haven apizza style as your probably going to find outside the area. Really good pizza!
matt.barron33/6/21, 12:15 a.m.
Tomatoes Apizza could hold their own on Wooster Street. Glad to have them here in Michigan.
ope.dope2/26/21, 12:49 a.m.
I’ll preface by saying this is my first time trying “New Haven” style. I wasn’t digging it. You’ve got a soupy middle that falls off when you pull a slice. The crust and bottom are too hard for my liking. Customer service was great, our order was wrong and they made a new pizza very quickly and comp’d us the wrong one. If you like this style maybe you’ll love it as a local option but it’s just not for me.
yousthepizzaguy2/25/21, 1:46 a.m.
Pretty Decent pizza. Thin and crispy crust but a tad bit salty overall. Would go there again.
aj.rudis2/19/21, 6:12 p.m.
Pretty good pizza little soupy in the middle. Nice crisp great undercarriage I did ask for a little Well Done
natalie.kearney2/13/21, 5:25 p.m.
Great pizza. Really good crust but could use a little more sauce.
david.oates2/11/21, 10:08 p.m.
This was amazing. Jumped in my car immediately after watching Dave eat it on YouTube. The dough is ON POINT! Crispy and chewy,, which is the perfect do consistency. Sauce had great flavor and cheese had the right fat content. When you fold a slice and you get that delicious grease that trickles down your hand. No napkin needed, because you don't waste a bit. Thats how good it was.
jenny3131/30/21, 9:16 p.m.
It was a good pizza. Not my favorite Michigan Pizza. I would compare it to Major Tomato in Allen Park but Major Tomato’s is much better! I like Supino’s in Detroit much more than this. Bit it is a good pizza.
melissa.rosenzweig1/25/21, 11:09 p.m.
Outstanding Overall, Best Pizza in town...World’s greatest Garlic Bread ... Period!
paulieegee7/28/20, 7:16 p.m.
Solid new haven style pizza. Best Pizza in MI - Supino, 112, 900, and all the other restaurants are all amazing but a caliber behind Tomatoes.