Tommy's Pizza

Although the regular slice was on the small side, the crunch is unreal, had a nice hold and the sauce was to die for. I can apply the same praise to the Sicilian slice too. Now I regret not having a small pie instead of slices. Superb pizza regardless.

Very unspecial pizza

Good forgot to take a picture of the pizza so took a photo outside

Vibe is immaculate. Pizza is very good. Wish I had some salt for the crust.. anyone else dip their crust in salt? Bit of flop, but super crisp crust. Juicy sauce and cheese.

Unique crust pushes this football pizza up a few notches

Immaculate🤌🏽

Real good. Crispy.

Great atmosphere. Good stringy cheese.

Great sauce! Good mix of cheese. Very consistent. Make it great every time. This is a high quality pizza. A must

Solid all around: crust, undercarriage, no flop, sauce/cheese ratio…and most importantly, it taste f’n great.

Already ate the cheese. Classically good pizza. Thin. Good crunch on the crust. Little too greasy for an 8

Here's what I will say. The undercarriage is top notch. 0 flop. The crust crisp is also beyond compare. The flavor in general wasn't enough to hit 8's. Certain bites near the crust were there but majority of the slice was missing that bite.

Disappointing.. The sauce was super bland the only compliment I have is that the dough was crispy. Dave might have lied on his rating just so he can make it out the Bronx safely. I get it but this was not a 8.6 pizza this is closer to a “5”

The one thing this place has going for it without a doubt is the aesthetic.. other than that the pizza lacked character, and flavor. It was cooked to perfection and crispy, but literally had no flavor from the sauce to the cheese, it was very disappointing to say the least. I can tell the locals are what keeps this place going, because the pizza is mediocre at best.

A rightfully deserved high 8s slice. Especially when Tommy is behind the counter. What’s not to like about this place

Absolutely delicious

Crust was bangin

A really good slice; checks all the boxes except it lacks a little in the taste department…just something is missing