Tony Boloney's - Hoboken

They have some wild creations. Really overpriced ($15 for a taco slice. Are you crazy?) They definitely should mix in some classics instead of offering only outlandish pizza. Taco slice tasted solid if you don’t look at the price tag? But the tikka masala pizza sucked

horrible service …. guy was miserable that i asked for 2 slices with 30 mins until close

Korean Mic Drop. Meh.

Never a fan but this time, honestly not bad

Simple jersey slice, no where near the best of Hoboken but gets the job done. Pretty thin but a little less greasy and it’s in the 7s

Good undercarriage. Flop on the front. Crispy undercarriage but soft crust. Decent sauce and cheese. 6.2.

It’s ok Frankie

Weird sauce. Slightly greasy. The girl at the counter looked like she wanted to be anywhere else.

VERY good margarita slice

General chicken specialty. One of the best pizzas I've ever tasted.

If you like specialty gourmet pies and food you HAVE to go to Tony boloneys this is my favorite specialty pizza spot ever

K-pop slice

I’m not a huge fan of gimmick pies, but if you’re looking for some truly crazy concoctions, this joint has a wide variety of “Stoner’s Pizzas” with some of the most unique toppings you’ll ever see on a pie. I’m rating solely based on their plain cheese pizza but I’m sure some of these specialty pies are delicious. The regular slice is kind of thickish, pretty nice crisp, decent flavored dough, very good crispy crust. The sauce isn’t anything special, not bad by any means but I expected a little more flavor. Lots of thick & stringy cheese throughout the pie, a little too extra cheesy to be honest, feels like I’m chewing bubble gum. Overall, it’s an average pie; I would probably try a specialty slice instead if you find yourself here. The regular cheese is basically “Drunk Pizza.” You can find plenty of better cheese slices in Hoboken.

Ok, so ordering a full pie is the way to go. Drastically different from getting a slice in person, and much better. Ordered it well done. Nice and crispy! Good chewy crust and nice sauce consistency.

Ok, not sure why but my other review for this place got deleted. Anyway, the taco slice is what theyre famous for so I pictured that. I’d say 7.7 for their plain slice & taco slice respectively though. And boy, was the latter a project eating.