Tony D's Pizza

Classic Football Pizza

A very good pie, not as thin of a crust as Angeloni’s (Caldwells other popular pizza place) but more of a traditional pizza style that is on the thin side. Slices had a bit of a flop, mostly from the cheese (I believe). Sauce was solid and the crust had very good flavor.

Really good football pizza

Really good pizza guys. Very crunchy and a little grease. Not very expensive. For how good it is. Enjoy

Really enjoyed it. Good crust, sweet sauce. Nice and light. No flop. Good crunch. Will come back.

Solid pizza, good cheese sauce ratio, excellent crust

Square was on point great crunch zero flop (except 4 middle but still not to bad) super thin and tasty...8.2 Round was no better then any football pie but on the thinner side...6.3

Solid thin slice... good sauce... not bad at all...

El Fugazidente low balls yet another score!

Another one I thought would be better based on the hype. Thin crust, decent flavor, but enough sauce and just didn't hit me.

It has a crispy crust and thats really all it has going for it. A thinner football buy with loads of grease.

Good not amazing but solid

Nothing to write home about. Uninspiring. Major let down. Kinda bland.

Drunken Grandma pie, great crunch and cheese, could’ve used a bit more of the vodka sauce. Quite good.

Good thin pizza. I liked it proper sauce and cheese mix. Caldwell NJ stop by on my way home on Friday...

still the best in NJ

This Pizza was incredible, the thin square was one of the better squares I’ve had. It was way better than Angeloni’s, this was real deal. Plain was also very good, both above average, and I think 8.7 is a fair score,