Tony D's Pizza

Pizza was good! Definitely a pizza icon you should visit when passing through Caldwell, NJ.

Plain slice: super thin. Zero flop. Really great taste! I could eat 10 slices of this. 7.9 Really wonderful people too! Bonus buffalo chicken slice: good undercarriage. Amazing crunch. They cut it into strips. Tender chicken (not chewy at all) Really good! 7.9 too! I will definitely be coming back here.

As good as you’ll get classic NY style!

Great pie, one if the best football pies around , old school pizzeria! One of best crusts , delicious

No photo. Just very good pizza

I already left a solid review for the standard cheese pizza but the grandma pizza is truly their bread and butter. Honestly the best square pizza I’ve had.

Thin crispy crust. Cheese had great taste.

Out of a tiny little side street, old school pizza shop comes this excellent, well balanced “thin crust but airy” pie. Real nice crisp, great sauce to cheese combo. A little bit greasy but very flavorful. Overall a great pie in what seems to be an Outstanding Pizza Town, Caldwell, NJ. Definitely worth the drive.

The crust was to thin the cheese was very nice and the sauce was very nice. overall very nice slice of pizza

Thin. Little greasy. Good pizza.

I really like the slice. It’s crispy, thin, pretty good sauce, I just wish it had more sauce on it.

9.4 One of the best in NJ if not the best.

No flop no crisp Not enough sauce

Round was just good pizza. Crust on the square was fantastic

Welcome to review number five. Tony D’s pizza was overall, pretty average. They got a pretty sweet menu, with 17 different speciality pizza options. I ordered a regular slice, and a whole drunken grandma pie. The drunken grandma was really good, and they used vodka sauce as the base, instead of tomato sauce. In this review I will be reviewing the regular slice, because it would not be fair to compare a specialty pie to the other regular pies I rated. This slice got a 7.2. Had a pretty good amount of flop. The cheese kept sliding off, which I find very annoying because you are two bites in and eating a piece of dough in a shape of a triangle. I tried a lot of good pizzas in the last month and this one did not compare.

Drunken Grandma’s pizza... vodka sauce wasn’t overpowering Not heavy at all , very good overall Would highly recommend

Classic Football Pizza

A very good pie, not as thin of a crust as Angeloni’s (Caldwells other popular pizza place) but more of a traditional pizza style that is on the thin side. Slices had a bit of a flop, mostly from the cheese (I believe). Sauce was solid and the crust had very good flavor.