paulfrommontauk4/16/21, 5:21 p.m.
Although it’s small & greasy, this true bar pie has flavor. The Oregano stands out. That’s Rich Battaglia commenting in the background bye the way.
3 views•0 likes
evenmartins3/29/21, 12:05 a.m.
Good bar pie, balanced and tasty. Old Atlantic City spot with new owner who thankfully kept the same recipes. Recommend the side of meatballs, the make a good gravy (tomato sauce) for it and don’t hold back on using it, the meatball parm as well.
rushfan-duhpizzareviewdude2/21/21, 5:47 p.m.
Crust nondescript, cheese nondescript, sauce very good. Overall, not very good.
8 views•1 like
parker1b22/1/21, 4:09 a.m.
Good pizza could that be a little more crispy. Great place and atmosphere. Really great service.
eric.hapshe1/29/21, 12:42 a.m.
In a rare dissention from prez, I found this pizza far more worthy. Sauce didn’t have much flavor, but the crust did. And zero flop, even with toppings. Pretty good pie. Did it seem worth $2 more than a plain pie from Stamford? No. But, I thought it was a FANTASTIC BAR PIE. Sorry Prez. You wrong bruh.
christine.hammett12/29/20, 1:00 a.m.
One of my favorite NJ pizzas. Perfect dough, great sauce, cheese just a tad greasy and I love it. Amazing!
anthony.phillips12/19/20, 11:19 p.m.
Don’t have a picture because I tossed the pizza in trash . Used my favorite pizza I don’t know what they changed maybe the ovens ? Or they’re not greasing the pans they cook the pizza in ? I don’t know but this pizza used to be a solid 8.9 maybe even a low 9 pie . Get it together I want the original Tony’s pie please .
raulfpizzacrew1/10/20, 11:23 p.m.
Very good bar pie, exactly what I expected. Sauce and cheese very good, no flop, Small enough where a family of 4 would need 2 pies.
ameo3112/30/19, 5:53 p.m.
Classic beach pizza- and for a $9 special you can’t beat it. The crust is the star; the cheese/sauce is fine but not special. Rare score I disagree with Pres on.
bigcase8/16/19, 6:05 p.m.
Wild pie, order sausage garlic well done, very nice crisp on the bottom awesome crust, homemade sauce was excellent almost 8.3, bartender was a legend 2.50buds
michael.cocosis8/10/19, 5:17 a.m.
Something about this sauce. It's amazing. It's drunk pizza, but the taste itself is slamming. They can't cut a pizza worth a shit though. This isn't a cutting rating. Go get this. Highly recommend the white clam 👍🏼.
chris.trabbold5/4/19, 7:17 a.m.
The best late-night drunk pizza in AC. With that said, it is just a mediocre pie when/if you’re ever sober. The redeeming factor is the crust, wow. It’s good crust. Cheese is heavy, sauce is saucey. But the crust and the butterfly shrimp will keep me coming back. Cheap beers til the break of dawn are cool too.
headshoes3/8/19, 11:09 p.m.
Very Tasty Bar Pie ... Classic Vintage Ambience ... Get the “Judge”... best pie on their menu
photoman3/2/19, 9:36 p.m.
Very Good Pizza, Crust was thin and crispy. Sauce was good, but lacking some spice. Overall one of the better pizza’s I have had in NJ.
sizzlebytizzle9/2/18, 4:44 p.m.
Follow me @sizzlebytizzle for travel and food 7.4 the special all mushroom all sausage sit at the bar order a pizza and relax #lifeoftizzle #sizzlebytizzle
407 views•1 like