Tony's Cafe

Crispy undercarriage, good balance of cheese and sauce, nice with pepperoni

Average for DE, though the place can’t even cook two pizzas in the same order consistently. Ordered NY style which it’s definitely not.

Solid football pizza. Cheese lunch special are an local staple, their specialty pizzas are where it's at though.

A nice firm crust that still had softness complemented by a solid blanket of cheese. Good sauce coverage with an interesting tangy taste. Overall a really good slice but I have a feeling the speciality slices are where it’s at here

So many great creations and so good!

Campells tomato soup as the marina sauce, and drunk pizza. Yuck!

Go to football pizza. Great flavor - sauce/cheese/topping ratio is spot on. Good dough - some flop and agree with other reviews on the grease but overall one of the best in Newark for a pepperoni slice

Disappointing. Very greasy. Had to much flop. No undercarriage. Sauce was very good but to much. I have had Tony’s in the past but this time was a big fail. In the past they have been spectacular.

My favorite family owned pizza restaurant I’ve ever been to. The owner is the nicest guy I’ve ever met

We got their Grandma pie. Not crispy at all, i'd ask for it we'll done next time. The taste was on point. From the dough, to the sauce.... Perfect amount of basil.... Kinda soupy, but the taste was there. This was surprisingly good (especially since we just got Angelo's in South Philly about a week prior). Get it well done and you got a very good pie!

Don’t have picture but some of the best pizza in the area. Highly recommend if in the area. Tony really knows how to make a pizza! Also their wings are pretty good to!

Fresh our the fire. Little heavy on the cheese and grease. Good flavors. Expectations were high, didn’t quite meet. Perfect game day pie.

Grandmom pie was very good.

If you want quality pizza in DE, with just the right crisp to the dough, fresh mozz, the right bite to sauce; Tonys is it. An easy 8.1. An 8.8 most likely if eaten right at their joint.

Tony’s is always a top quality slice ! For a treat ask for the Chocolate pizza !