Tony's New York Pizza

Decent pie. Cheese crust could have used another minute or two in the oven. Meat had a better undercarriage.

Good slice of pizza. No flop, good undercarriage, descent crisp. Sauce is tasty and the cheese to sauce ratio is balanced.

One of the better pizzas in Haymarket.

Best 7.5 in the real world. 9.5 in this area of bad pizza

OG spot. Pretty pizza. Slightly soupy in the middle. Greasy and cheesy. Crispy towards the end of the slice. A tad salty. Overall a solid pizza. Tony is a great man and I’ll come back forever. The cheese steaks are ridiculous, along with most of his dishes.

Chewy cheese, a little greasy but excellent flavor. Big slices with excellent sauce to cheese ratio. Crust is thin and hard.

Sicilian square, definitely not your typical pizza. Sauce was interesting (good) crust had a great crunch and cheese was great!

This is part of the others I think. Owner super friendly and Italian for sure. Clean place and friendly service. Pizza is just as good as the others in the “chain”. If you’re in Gainesville or haymarket it’s worth the drive here or the one down in Bristow.