Tony's New York Pizza

Good family pie, I always put stuff on top. Next time I’ll order it well done. Good stuff.

Place is a total shithole inside but the slices looked pretty sharp. Didn’t taste quite as good as they looked though. Real thin and a bit of flop, first slice fell apart when folded. Toward the crust had some more crisp. Overwhelmingly salty and not much taste from the sauce

I for some reason ordered a Scililian style. Not my normal go too so score doesn't reflect the regular pizza. Loved the pizza, next time I'd ask for extra sauce on this because the extra bread

It took forever and it wasn’t great. Probably should have gotten a whole pie.

Best crispy pie from Tony’s. Perfect crisp and nice sauce. Good cheese and not too much oil.

A little doughy this time but really good

Generous score for this stale and flavorless slice. Inedible without ranch, pepper or parm

Little flop good crunch. Always good

Very high flop, flavorful tomato sauce, zesty pepperonis

Light Reheat, limited floppies, fine crackle crust, sauce was the standout on this slice and minimal grease protruding from the cheese.

Medium flop, little hefty on the cheese, and great pepperoni ratio.