Tonys N.Y. Pizza

A little on the cheesy doughy side

Great pizza. Crust is incredible, crispy and lots of flavor. A lot of great slice options to choose from

The most authentic NY slice I have had. Blows away many in the NYC metro area. It takes a while to get this pizza and I understand why. Fantastic slice.

Pretty Good Slice! Crunchy crust and cornicione. Cheese had a buttery quality to it but was a touch greasy. Sauce is good, but simple.

I’m trying all the pizza near my vacation condo in Ft. Myers. This was okay. They could have warmed the slice a little more, cheese quality left a bit to be desired, crispy undercarriage with minimum fwop, sauce on the bland side. Would like to try a fresh cheese slice or at very least a hot pizza next time.

They have the best Hawaiian pizza I’ve ever had, A++. But, my favorite type of pizza is Margherita, and it’s slightly better than Fine Folk. Crust is phenomenal, sauce is good (will order extra sauce next time), and the mozzarella was just okay. The premier spot for specialty pizzas in Fort Myers.

Very good but not great

If you’re looking for a plain cheese, Pizza Delux is still the place to go in South Fort Myers. However, if you want specialty pies or any ingredients on top, it’s Tony’s