Tony's Pizza Ballantyne

Honestly the more I kept eating this pie, the more I hated it. I asked for well done, this is what I got. Lots of flop, cheese had no flavor and had a weird gooey/soft texture to it (not chewy), sauce was underwhelming. Also wings were terrible, not sauced they just give you a container to dip.

Sauce is very flavorful with almost no flop. Not too greasy. If it was cooked a little longer the score would be higher. Overall a good slice that I’d get again.

Strong crust. Delicious cheese. Tasty sauce.

Best place around Ballantyne

Good crust and above average undercarriage. Huge pizza slice! Cheese is meh, too much and not cooked enough for me to warrant a higher score.

The most average pizza you can get. It’s not bad, it’s just not good either. Everything is average with this pizza.

Great crust, tad greasy or would have been higher.

Nice, sweet sauce. Crispy undercarriage. Quality pie. Huge 24” pies at this place. Had a cannoli after. We struggle to find good NY pie down south. This reminds me of home.

Needs to be kept in the oven longer. Underwhelming

This is the real fucking deal. I’ve had better but not west of the Delaware River.

Little greasy, heavy flop, solid cheese/sauce combo

Not too much flop, nice and tight. Very thin but holds it's own. Perfect cheese to sauce ratio. Very little grease. A very good football pizza.

Not too much flop. Good crisp. Sauce and sauce ratio are excellent.

A little flop, good flavor, good crisp.