Tony's Pizza

Since 1950 Frankie, you can tell.

Nostalgic bite, nostalgic pizza. A perfect Brooklyn pie. If you want old fashion Brooklyn pizza, none of this artisan crap. None of this I failed out of culinary school so now I work for a pizzeria bull crap. This is the slice for you. This is the ahhpeetz for you. Legendary spot.

This is a Brooklyn slice. Great crisp and undercarriage here. Didn’t go too heavy on the oregano either,just let the cheese and sauce speak for itself.

Good Crust. Nice and light. Sauce was on point.

Sicilian gets an8.2

Great slice

Very good pizza

Disappointing, considering this score is over a full point below Dave’s score; floppy, oily, and little-to-no sauce. Needed to take a shower after eating this pizza. On top of being oily, the slice was $3 and I paid with a $20 and got $17 in singles back..might as well call this place Tony’s Pizza and Strip Club. Carmine’s across the street is far superior.

Good slice. Salty. Nice crunch.

Cash Only but good slice. One of my favorites around here.

Very good slice! Crust was perfect cheese and sauce are fine. Great walking slice. Standard NYC slice

The first thing that jumped out at me about this pizza was how amazingly firm it was...ZERO flop, a harder dough with lots of crunch. Great crust, very crispy. That being said, the cheese & sauce leave a lot to be desired. Pretty standard cheese but very tight and congealed...lacking that creamy, oozing flow you’d expect from hot pizza cheese. The sauce is absolutely flavorless, no pizzazz whatsoever. It’s a shame because the firm dough provides an excellent base for the beginnings of a very good pie; but the sauce & cheese disappoint tremendously. I also deducted points after finding a few rogue pieces of pepperoni. Very sloppy and careless on Tony’s part. Dave must have been in a really good mood when he rated this joint because scoring this mediocre pie the same as L’industrie is CRIMINAL! Don’t buy in to the boosted ratings; some clown on here gave this place a 10. It’s extremely average pizza and shouldn’t even be a blip on the NYC map.

Thin slice

Very good pizza!

A slice with NO flop, WELL DONE undercarriage, CRISPY crust. A solid slice overall. Not in the 8s because of the slight grease from the cheese. Perfect balance of cheese, dough, and sauce. A solid slice.