Tony's Pizza Cafe

Easily a mid 8 pizza. So much choices as well no brainer to try this one.

Very good NY Style pie, the best pizza spot that’s past J&S in Natrona Heights. Same vibe as J&S (same family), mostly eyeing up their sauce on this one. Delicious ingredients and great spot. Will be back. Big fan.

Overall one the best pizza shops in western PA ! Decent undercarriage still has some flop . A bit too much grease but still a great slice

Some fresh tomato pie. Made me feel like I was back home. This place is so great.

Had some good morning pizza today. I was going to stop into this place at 11AM when it said they opened, but I got there around 10:45 and the place was already packed. I knew at that point I was going to get a decent slice. The pizza was very floppy. My first bite all of the cheese fell off. Once I picked it up it tasted very good. The sauce was on the runny side and not very flavorful until you got until the outer rim of the pizza where it really stood out. The people inside were so nice and I thought the pizza was very good. The last couple of times I’ve been in Butler county I’ve gotten some good pizzas, no wonder it’s growing so much!

Super floppy, super greasy, but not too bad

Good pizza. New York style pictured here. Above average NY style. If going to Tony’s order the tomato pie or Sicilian.

Great undercarriage. Little flop. Great slice

Little flop. NY style pizza. Good pizza Dave would enjoy it.

Best pizza around , hands down. Even beats J&S

Solid pizza. Good crunchy crust. Not greasy.

Alright Frankie, Tony’s pizza has one of the best Sicilian slices in the area. It tastes 10x better than the picture. Ample amount of cheese, perfect sauce to cheese ratio, and the crust is light and crisp, but also has a crunch. Some Sicilian crusts are hard and bland, but this one balances crisp and airy. Their NY style pizza is good too, but I think as far as taste goes, their Sicilian pizza wins this one.

Sicilian 8.5 NY 7.4 Grand mom 7.6 A+ people!

Stuffed Meat always blowing my balls off