Tony's Pizza

Solid pizza

Crust was not floppy. Dee dish was good but not great, I do recommend

Lost the picture to the regular slice but this is really good, can taste the basil... not my favorite condiment but I can understand why some like it... still makes it delicious... the biggest problem with this thing is the flop... causing the pizza to tear had it crispy and crunchy throughout the whole slice It would've surpassed the 8 mark.... cheese is nice doesn't pull and make a mess.... and the cheese and sauce ratio is perfect... is a shame with flop and break... other wise it would've been higher..

This lacks a lot of game for a football pie. No crisp, doughy, and floppy . And the sauce had no flavor.

Major flop too much cheese not bad for football pizza but not go out of your way pizza

Great sauce great cheese, crust is crispy, minimal flop

Plain slice had great crust, thin and crispy but not burnt. Sauce was good but missing that little tang. Good cheese, a little too much for me and slightly greasy but not enough to complain about. 6.7 BONUS REVIEWS: Deep dish was WAY TOO cheesy for me. I expected a thick slice with some cheese. I got a thin slice with 2 lbs of cheese. The pie came fresh out of the oven and the crust was soft and undercooked. The sauce was good though. 5.1 No bottles or cans of Dr. Pepper. Fountain pepper was decent. 6.1

Pretty good slice all around. A little greasy, Sauce had great flavor, a little too much cheese for me but nothing crazy.

Love tonys. Best classic regular I've had in years! Great crisp no flop.

The first bite was not so good because it was too thin but right when you get past the first half of the pizza it turns out to be an excellent slice. Overall not a bad slice.

Great crust ,nice cheese , not to much floppy solid pizza

One Bite... huge slices, right off the bat you can smell the parmigiana cheesed baked in. Cheese is amazing thick and sauce goo ratio between crust, sauce, cheese. The sauce is great, I would like it a little less sweet but it’s great pizza. Tony’s on 112 on Long Island, that’s my pizza review.

The best slice you’ll find in Suffolk county