Download
Home
Top Restaurants
Tony's Pizza New York Style
Tony's Pizza New York Style
6975 A1A South, St. Augustine, Florida
0 likes
evasivetear
5 days ago
Super flop but really great taste. Parmesan, garlic and oregano flavors with great cheese and sauce. Only criticism I have is that it is always a super long wait. Still, happy we got it.
vinsurfandmusic
10/11/23, 2:23 p.m.
6.1
The pizza has a good overall taste and we like it but you can see the flop is way too much. We actually cooked it more and you can see the difference in the picture. Also cheese needs to get to the edge of the sauce by the crust! We have had better here so maybe it was very busy.
0 likes
andrew.brooks
1/28/23, 12:48 a.m.
8.7
Asked for extra crisp and it delivered. Great pie and very nice people! Had to wait a little extra because they had a rush and he gave me a free baklava and brownie.
0 likes
b.mac2
4/20/22, 3:41 p.m.
7.1
Did it deserve a 7.1, probably not… but I was hungry. The cheese was the best part, crust was fluffy but not too much flavor. Sauce needs improvement and the za was floppy. There was some dried basil sprinkled on top of the center. I liked the basil but it could be a negative if you don’t like basil. In the end, forgettable but decent if u want a some pizza
0 likes
dew-pizza
8/4/21, 11:29 p.m.
6.9
Solid pizza. A tad greasy but good. Crust has excellent flavor.
0 likes
josh.espey
7/21/21, 10:12 p.m.
5.7
Cheese was good. Little too much flop and wasn’t a fan of the sauce. Garlic knots were delicious though
0 likes
camden.millheiser
6/11/21, 9:29 p.m.
6.8
Floppy but still solid. Decent crust and cheese. I think it could have used more sauce.
1 like
rjvieldy
12/14/19, 6:47 p.m.
6.0
0 likes
jeffrey.wood
8/13/19, 4:48 p.m.
7.2
Had slices this time, a little better. Crispy crust and very flavorful cheese and sauce. Good pizza.
2 likes
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
YouTube
© 2026 Barstool Sports. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Content Policy
Contact Us
App Support