Tony's Pizza

Great slice, super great family vibe. Perfect neighborhood hole-in-the-wall. Feels like NYC. Amazing sauce. A little floppy

Grandmas pizza, with meatballs on half Solid all around. Too much grease (wouldn’t add meatballs next time, should help reduce it some). Wish it had a little more crunch in the crust. Solid ingredients and flavor.

This was so disappointing. Zero flavor, and everything fell apart in to a huge greasy pile when I picked up a slice. The crust felt good, it had crisp but was still fluffy inside. But that’s the only thing keeping it out of the 3’s. No structure on the rest of the slice, no seasoning. Oof.

Might be the best pizza out here at the beach. I have tried all the others and this is it .

Definitely New York style. Not bad but not great, little on the greasy side

Pretty good pizza for Jax. Greasy and floppy (even the plain cheese that I also tried). Good taste, good crust, but missing something that will grab your attention. No zing. Same people that owned the Jax Beach pizza parlor at Pablo 5 in the old days. I thought it was best pizza in the world back then. But in those days I didn’t have much craft. Just a little native ability.

Pretty solid taste, but a little too greasy

Good crust, great taste, no flop, light “The grandma” straight from Italy Plus free bruschetta while you wait