Tony's Pizzeria

Best slice I’ve ever had. Real New York slice when freshly heated. Great crisp real Italian speaking guy runs the place they close at 9 on a Friday cause they know what they got. 8.8

My favorite pizza in Watertown, slices are large and crispy, great flavor

Last stop before I head home to Buffalo! This place has been OIP for quite a few years now. Pizza places in Watertown change names often but there’s some tenure with this place... Nice and crispy! Love a re decked slice! It is on the greasy side but not overwhelming so. The pepperoni is large and thin. The cheese is standard and unfortunately I would like to have just a little bit more sauce. Not a lot of flavor to go with the crunch. This pizza is surprisingly better than Cam’s (on the square). Easily an 8 with a little more sauce.

Pretty good slice!

Ordered a 16” . Burned the roof of my mouth. Has a little crisp. Greasy. Almost no flop.

No standard cheese pizza available to review. Got a white slice. Floppy as shit. No real flavor. Greasy as hell. Not recommended.

Nothing special, sauce has little flavor. Grease pit of a slice.

This is from a pie, single slices are bigger and NY style. Pizza is good. But the real show stopper here are the subs. High quality toppings No flop