I love this grouchy old man. Truly an underrated spot. I’ve been going here for 10 years on and off this guy has a unique pie with a very sweet sauce and it’s truly enjoyable. He puts pride into his pies and you can really taste it. The old dough machine is super neat too. Don’t let his poor attitude steer you away he means well.
spiceymeatballs10/27/20, 1:42 p.m.
You walk in , you think old school pizzeria . This is a hidden gem , there was no flop, had a great crunch, the sauce was had a little tang and very very good. The price of the pies are also old school. One of best pies I have had ...
ryan.rutherford9/5/20, 4:02 a.m.
I wasn’t expecting much from this little pizzeria but this pie definitely exceeded all expectations. The star of this pizza is the SAUCE! Super sweet, like a combination of sugar garlic and onions, but delightfully delectable and very unique. There is a distinct flavor that separates it from most basic pies. The cheese is creamy and spread perfectly throughout, with terrific texture. The dough is similar to a deep fried zeppole, but nice and thin and incredibly tasty. The only area that could use a little improvement is the fat, soft & doughy crust. A little thinner and a tad crispier and this pie catapults into the 8s. Very good overall, a nice old school Italian neighborhood pizza pie.
john.pepe37/1/20, 10:59 p.m.
Honestly this pie is the best in the area and there are many to compare with but Tony’s takes the pie! Such an amazing pizza and behind the counter is tony an old Italian guy who loves making his pizza. Everything about this place is great!
forgetaboutit6/15/20, 10:17 p.m.
What a tasty pie!! Definitely a NYC style! Very authentic and off the boat. Excellent crust! So tasty and crispy, kind of thin but texture. Sauce is out of this world! Has a tasty sweet but not thick.. i really like this pie Franky! Dave should review this place, really off the boat and authentic pizza.. may be one of the best around. Plussss 10$! Thought he was messing with me lol so yes, the score was had a extra 0.2 cause pizza that good is worth 20$ and they charge 1/2zzz got to love that!
frank.pollock11/27/19, 10:02 p.m.
Handmade right in front of you upon order. Sweet sauce style is a great comfort pizza.