Trophy Pizza - Evendale

So good!!! I always get pepperoni and they were very generous. Perfect balance of cheese and sauce. Crust had that good oven flavor if you know what I mean. Undercarriage was good not great or would have been a 9. Try the meatballs!!

Greasy and a lot of flop. Crust chewy not crisp. Taste was okay.

Decent Pie! The flavors are great! great flop and undercarriage. the crust stood out to me with the char and having a great crunch to it. The only problem i had, was it had some grease to it where you would need a napkin to dap it. but other than that. it a solid pie!

Consistently good every time I have it! A must try! It’s the grandma pie!

Fantastic pizza! Good crunch! Great flavor!

Both my boys gave it a 10 definitely will go back only an hour.5 away!

Banger pie.

A little flop but Great flavored sauce. Nice crunch on the crust.

Got a half cheese, half sausage pie. Not bad. Definitely cooked well with a tasty crunchy crust. All their pizzas were coming out of the oven well-done (dark crust). Huge pizza. They only sell one size. Good taste. I liked the sauce a lot. My wife loved it but wished there was more cheese on it. I thought the cheese to sauce ratio was perfect. Very friendly staff working there. Will go back. They also sell by the slice.

Best NY style in Cincinnati, perfect crisp. The photo, just look at it 👀!

Best pizza in Cincinnati

Basing just off cheese Trophy is a low to mid 8. The loophole is what you come here for. Do yourself a favor and get a slice of cheesecake made in house. The real secret.

“This is good pizza” - My 2 year old son.

A little greasy. Crisp crust. Amongst the best in Cincinnati.

As close as you are going to find in the Nati for an authentic NY style slice. You can tell this is made with love from the fresh ingredients that show themselves in the sauce made from scratch to the dough that has the NY "flop" at the end to the crisp and crunch at the back. If you haven't given it a try I would highly recommend getting here. Score will be for the NY slice. I was also given a complimentary sicilian style slice that was given to me graciously to give a try. For a first time try it is definitely very good. I would maybe give it a little more cook time to crisp it up a little more but overall a very solid slice as well with room for some improvements. i will give the Sicilian a 7.4. TROPHY PIZZA is in fact your go to if you are looking for true authentic NY style pizza.