brandon.williams53/11/20, 9:51 p.m.
Little greasy, needs to be little more crisp on bottom.. still decent slice
yan.idrissov3/4/20, 12:41 a.m.
huge flop, crust not crunchy . had better , had worse. go for the deep dish.
bigdaddysouthy2/26/20, 9:36 a.m.
Good flavor all around; fresh sauce and toppings, light and airy crust, medium flop. A little overpriced, but worth the wait every now and then. 7.3!
donjavid2/19/20, 6:43 p.m.
Good pizza. Has a nice sauce to cheese ratio. I personally would have liked a little crispier bottom. Overall good pizza.
leesponseller12/21/19, 10:49 p.m.
Gotham Gangster is outta this world. A must try when you’re in the area.
barstool-craig11/9/19, 12:07 a.m.
Two Cities, so you know I had to get two pizzas! Let me start with that I heard all the hype around this pizza and I knew I had to go in as unbiased as possible......but let me tell you baby. This. Shit. Slaps. I’ve always been a thin crust guy and this crispy buttery crust doesn’t disappoint, but the crown jewel is the DEEP DISH. This has got to be the best sauce on a pizza I have ever had! If I had to describe it in one word, it would be “Tangy”. Believe the hype people, because the price is worth every bite.
jordan.green510/12/19, 1:29 a.m.
These reviews are way too high. Floppy. Sauce tasted like it’s store bought. Tough, chewy, cardboard crust. Just not good and def. won’t eat again.
john.daumeyer10/5/19, 1:32 a.m.
Really good. Crust was great, sauce was really good. Flop was good. Definitely recommend. Side note: Pitrelli’s is down the street and for some reason not on the app. Too bad, because it’s great pizza.
chris.malloy29/26/19, 12:24 a.m.
Lots of flop lots of grease. Nice sauce and cheese. Crust has good texture but little flavor. Lg pizza is a small.
brandon.brydges9/14/19, 10:22 p.m.
Good attempt at NY style pizza. Excellent for pizza in the Midwest. Good crust, could have crisped it a bit more. House ranch is on point.
timothy.perry8/28/19, 5:04 p.m.
Large Cheese Pie - $15.99 Everything was homemade. Absolutely loved the crust and sauce. Cheese was great. Happy house 11-4 Sunday through Thursday. Great patio. NOW... Could’ve been a higher score but it’s not really big. Kinda small for a “New York Style” but I still loved the taste
barry.pulskamp8/12/19, 4:05 p.m.
Had both the New York and the Chicago style. Both were great.
brad.nietz7/20/19, 2:24 a.m.
Lot of flop, but still crispy crunch. Sauce is sweet, good tasting, solid pizza.
cusepizzafan6/8/19, 9:41 p.m.
The scores for this place are way too high. This is a 6.8 all day. Solid, but nothing special. Good crust and cheese. Too greasy. BTW, Chicago style is a 5.8.