Tyler's Pizzeria

Really good pizza. A lot of flop. Somewhere between Neapolitan and NY style pizza.

Decent pizza! Could’ve been a little more crispy but overall good pie

great dough, not my fav sauce

Good solid pizza in Columbus.

Very good dough, coming from a bakery, it is typically going to be a little bit thicker- similar to hand-tossed in style. I wish it was cooked a little bit more so it had a crisper undercarriage and a little less flop- it’s really close, next time I think if I order it well done and it will be great. Quality ingredients, solid 7.6. Perk of this place is it has baked goods too, and damned good ones at that! Loved the fresh pumpkin chocolate brownies

1/2 cheese, 1/2 sausage pep. Really good taste. The crust was a little done but that is what you usually get with this style.

The crust was a little too done for me but the staff was nice.

Local artisan bakery and pizzeria. Best pizza in Columbus!

I so wanted to love this pizza and my disappointment from not loving it may have led me to be too harsh in my scoring. The crust is what you would expect from a bakery, the best part. The sauce is perfectly fine, none of that sweet nonsense. Cheese is just basic. Basil is a little heavy in my opinion and I specifically requested no tomatoes, they put fresh tomato slices atop their Margherita pizzas. I definitely would not drive an hour for this but the quality ingredients gets it into the 7’s.

Great crust, can’t go wrong here. Quality ingredients, friendly service. The sauce is a little herby for me. But I do like a Tyler’s pie about once a month.

Well done, no flop. Super fluffy, place is top notch.

Definitely the best pizza in REYNOLDSBURG

Tyler’s Pizzeria and Bakery uses only fresh ingredients and a wood fired stove. Pizza comes out crisp every time. The best pizza in Columbus and it’s not close

Crust was pretty decent but the pizza lacked flavor for me. Definitely didn’t blow my mind.Would I travel out of my way to go here? No. That’s just me though.