Slightly above average slice. There was nothing bad about it but, at the same time nothing really stood out. The crust was crunchy, good. The cheese and sauce were... meh... A little bland but, I would not say bad. Throw some crushed red pepper and a little pecorino Romano and kick it it up a notch.
ryandechen3/19/21, 10:31 p.m.
best grandma i’ve had from here. they can be inconsistent but this was very good
noah.lam12/14/20, 9:47 p.m.
This one is located in Lake Grove and not New Hyde Park Regular Slice 6.8 Margherita 6.9
juan.rivera26/20/20, 12:37 a.m.
Great slice everything balanced, nothing horrible nothing super great but really good, only issue is burnt crust
jay.marine2/19/20, 10:16 p.m.
Finally!! A great slice! Thin. lil crisp. Little extra grease, but that never bothered me none, bring it on... great ratios: right amount of cheese, sauce great, the tiniest of flop, barely noticeable. I could get fat on this place, easy peasy. The local pizza places should stop by and try a slice.... up there game... ay ohhhh. Side note: everything is good here, not just the regular. I’m glad I work close by. I usually get the grandma or Sicilian...
sushiguy1/19/20, 1:45 a.m.
Firm slice. Good amount seasonings in the sauce. Definitely, onecof Suffolk County's better pizzas.
chris.bozza11/24/19, 4:26 p.m.
regular slice was perfectly cooked amazing crunch amazing doe little bit of oil... this is the best pizza on long island they straight up took over . when you go to this place nothings been sitting for more than 20 minutes ... they always got fresh slices .... so this score is based off the regular slice it was perfect ... couldn’t ask for a better slice
andrew.lembo10/2/19, 4:19 p.m.
Pizza tastes a bit over cooked. Crust tastes burnt and cheese tastes burnt too. Sauce is good though.
itsrickyrose8/4/19, 2:35 a.m.
Half sausage half grandma. Very good slice, very crispy and crunchy. A bit greasy and would be higher score if less greasy. Sauce has a great tang to it. Very good pizza and very consistent.
bestpizzalonguyland7/2/19, 10:02 p.m.
Good cheese solid crust. Sauce is decent. Very good well rounded slice. Bonus The special slice here I got is amazing though. Gets bumped from 8.1 to 8.4. dave check it out one of best ones in suffolk
michelle.jordan16/23/19, 11:44 p.m.
this slice of pizza is really good but just a tad bit greasy but a lovely slice to chomp down on.
steven.hennessy6/15/19, 4:50 p.m.
Pizza done right! Crispy, sauce good tang, cheese not to oily! Sicilian slice even better 8.9!
zachary.worthington6/9/19, 7:16 p.m.
Best pizza in Long Island? Pffffff. Its good, not great. I know they are more known for their Sicilian so i tried it, it was slightly too done, but the dough was very good. The sauce is nothing special. Cheese, i think they use a blend because im getting something different from it, a more pungent cheese flavor. Not a bad thing but not a wow factor. The plain slice was good, not spectacular. Little flop, sauce was ehhhhh. Same cheese as the square i had. I expected more from this place.
shadymilkman5/3/19, 4:49 p.m.
One bite everyone knows the rules If you're from Long Island and even want to consider yourself at best AA in the pizza game you need to review Umberto's. This place is a fucking long island institution with ppl screaming from rafters about how this is the best square pizza in town.... Well I'm the fucking pro so I'm going to be the judge of that. We all know the rules the score is based on the round pie. It's the Batman of the pizza universe. If you can't love Batman you have no business in the game. Looking at this slice initially I wasn't impressed. It looked like the type of slice where they try and get fancy on me and put a bunch of bullshit in the sauce to satisfy the chefs culinary muscle.... Picking up this slice and giving the standard NY fold let out an audible crunch that could be heard all the way up in the cheap seats at Citi field. I knew this was going to be an adventure. QUALITY is the only way I can describe this Pizza. The sauce tastes like fucking tomatoes and nothing else. Pizza sauce should be tomatoes, olive oil and salt NOTHING ELSE. The sauce had the perfect amount of tang. It was the best pizza sauce I've had in a Family slice on Long island by far. The cheese had great oil and you can tell it was a skim Mozz. The crust was perfectly crisp if not alittle charred. This is pizza you fucking drive to and tell your friends about. That's a review!