Umbertos of Massapequa Park

Rally good pizza I got a Sicilian and buffalo chicken the buffalo chicken slice was a 8.6 one of the best buffalo chicken I ever had and the the Sicilian was a hit and was a 9.1

Delivered on a Monday night. Presentation solid, no flop on the pickup. Cheese pull solid. Cheese sauce ratio a little heavy to me. But overall flavor was lacking. was looking for a little more.

Obvious box party foul. However the sauce is sweet and tasty. Crunch and ratios are present. Overall enjoyed and would recommend. Restaurant side looked nice as well.

OG Grandma

Maybe it’s because I’m from Michigan but always loved New York pizza but this is the first 9 I’ve ever scored! That’s combing the Cheese and the Buffalo Chicken slice. The Buffalo Chicken slice I can eat all day!

Rookie score but this is the right score for this place. Perfectly balanced tomato sauce, nice dough and just the right of cheese. This would be my Goto place if I lived in the area

Both the regular and sicilian were from fresh out of the oven pies The regular was doughy and soggy and tasted bland The sicilian was horrible. Nothing good about it

I have only had the margarita pie at this pizza place. I have no interest in any of the other pizzas because this pizza is so spectacular. I note that the reviews for this place are not as high as my review is but that is because virtually all of them, if not all of them, are for other pizzas they have available. If you want incredible margarita pizza, order a 10 inch personal or a full sized pie. The dough is light and crisp but not too light and not too crispy. It blends perfectly with the properly proportioned amount of sauce, basil and cheese. Outstanding pizza.

Solid slice. Hear the Grandma is the way to go at this spot.

Good solid football pizza, all around very good slice. Was hoping crust would be a little crispier, even ordered it well done. Very good but not elite. Would def get again. RIP Harambe

Super crunchy, not too gressy and sauce is good.

Proper slice. Well done crust, good sauce, not too greasy, no flop, crispy, and just the right amount of cheese. This slice is a winner

Very cheesy, thick sauce with doughy crust. Not a bad slice but it’s scored too high by the community at an 8.1.

Solid pizza. Would eat again. Umberto’s

First review so I gotta give a rookie score. Decent slice but sauce is ......ehh. maybe too much oregano. I'd stop if hungry when passing but wouldn't go out of my way.