Umberto's of Sayville

Solid chicken marsala slices. Chicken pieces were tiny, and pizza was very greasy. Great quality mozzarella.

Always solid

I tried the pan pizza here and loved it. Buttery crust with quality mozzarella and a hearty marinara. The chicken Marsala slice was heavy on the mushrooms. Chicken Parm slice was cheap on the chicken.

Pizza was ok , definitely one of the better spots in sayville

Good pizza

Really good slice for what is considered a chain. Every bite was super flavorful and had a decent amount of crunch. The slice had a bit of flop and little oily, but LI football slices don’t get much better.

Best pizza around

Fresh out of the oven house pie, hot and crispy, cooked perfectly. Might have found my new favorite spot.

Solid slice. Zero flop, good crunch, and the crust had bubbles ( always a + in my book)

not as good as the floral park location but as good as any around here

8.1 super good

Good sauce and cheese Ratio and portion of ingredients were perfect Good crunch

Good LI pizza, nothing spectacular

Regular: greasy floppy and salty, sauce seems a bit watered down. Not close to umbertos of NHP 6.4 Sicilan: good crunch to this slice, sauce and cheese are excellent. Not quite umbertos of NHP but a good substitute. 8.1 Grandma: to much garlic and not crispy enough to be called a grandma slice from umbertos of NHP 6.9

Really tasty, crunchy.... one of better slices of Suffolk... it loses decimal points on stability... like the cheese fell off at points cuz of semi flop but this is still amazing pizza... also their chicken parm slice is amazing 9.1 it'd be even higher if it didn't come apart... like the chicken fell off but still some of the best pizza in Suffolk so far

Meh

Delicious slice. Healthy amount of cheese and a sweet sauce. Big time flop

Scalice girls, Kyla, Sadie and Scarlett, Video review. Family score average of 6.7 Mom = 5.2 Dad = 5.4 Kyla = 6.0 Sadie = 7.0 Scarlett = 100 (we will call it a 10)

Had to redo the score from last time. Best pie yet.

Review based solely off the cheese slice. Greasy and a cheese lava explosion, but the cheese sauce and crust are all good. It’s a solid slice, not blow your dick off but it’s good.