18,643 views•124 likes
navysteve1/14/24, 1:25 a.m.
Tried three pies all were delicious. Grandma of course is what they are known for and has to be the best grandma I’ve ever tasted. Note, the place is two restaurants in one. There is a fancy side that does not serve pizza for some weird reason.
michaelandsampizzareviews12/27/23, 7:07 p.m.
Finally my boyfriend and I got to try one of the most popular pizza places on Long Island! We tried the plain slices, I gotta say it’s the BEST pizza I ever tasted!!! Especially since it’s the best pizza on Long Island! The grandma slice is just as good. Grandma Slice: 9.0 Michael’s rating: 10! Grandma Slice: 9.8
cjaquilino9/24/23, 6:45 p.m.
From the One Bite Fest, reviewing all this in retrospect is harder. I’ll be honest and say the details of this one wasn’t memorable besides that they offered a round and grandma. But I remembered they’re more known for their grandma. I feel like I remember the crust was more like a thinner pillowy Sicilian than one with a high edge crust. I do like that better as it’s something different. Can’t remember much else about the slices though.
brooklyngreg9/2/23, 10:57 p.m.
Regular slice Crust is nicely well done. It's a little too thick for my liking. The rest is pretty standard though. Birthplace of the grandma slice but I've had much better.
popzeus8/29/23, 3:51 a.m.
I’m reviewing the grandma pie. By far their best slice and one the best slices in NY
joeymontz7/7/23, 12:07 a.m.
UNBELIEVABLE Crust and crisp Sicilian Slices were amazing had the perfect ratio of sauce to cheese to bread(9.1) Brick Oven Pizza had great undercarriage with a really great crisp and all around flavor, but a tad greasy(8.9) Great building with really cool old Italian architecture, great atmosphere inside P.S. The free bread and garlic knots were perfect
nelson.joseph7/3/23, 12:56 a.m.
Good crisp and sauce, but could reduce the cheese. As a result the pizza was a little heavier than what I typically like.
sam.kahane6/4/23, 10:27 p.m.
Wouldn’t plan my day around it - in fact, I’d hold my hunger and drive the hour to Little Vincent’s. Sauce was sour, cheese was soupy, and the medley of different slices helped in no way. Crust was the best part, and if I had to choose - go sicilian
frank.reese5/19/23, 4:55 p.m.
Big slices. A tad greasy. But amazing taste. Great crunch. Great undercarriage. Zero flop. The original Umbertos delivers. Get here if you can.
duncan.lundy5/11/23, 4:29 a.m.
This pizza was great- both the regular and the Sicilian. Buy these two roasted slices in my picture were what I got when I asked for them “not too hot”. If fairness, the water was pretty clueless altogether.