Kinda disappointed in the plain slice... it was nothing to write home about. But Umberto’s is known for the Grandma slice and it was incredible. Like 9.3 incredible. Never had a better Grandma. I’ll go back and order three Grandmas every time. That good.
danny.miller117/25/21, 10:55 p.m.
Awesome Pizza Joint. All 3 slices I tried are in the 8s... The regular is a strong 8.6 with great flavors and good texture. a bit heavy and thick but not so much in a bad way. The grandma had my favorite texture, being so thin & crisp, but it was still a bit sweet for me. 8.0. The Sicilian was my favorite at 8.9 - amazing sauce, cheese, & flavors. a tad thick & bready, but that's what Sicilian should be. Delicious spot
pablo.lopez6/27/21, 2:04 a.m.
Got the grandma pie. Delicious. Best pizza I've had in the immediate area while visiting family!
mcrobrez16/7/21, 10:47 p.m.
Hit the Sauce Jackpot!!! Knew this place had good reviews and ratings and was super surprised that it was that good. The slice is top notch in terms of sauce. Very flavorful, you can tel the sauce is good quality, seasoned with spices. Crust was just as good, crunchy bit overly burnt. Zero flop and no oil just adds to it. Currently, my second favorite slice of all time!!!
ethan.mizrahi5/30/21, 6:58 p.m.
Real good pizza, regular cheese scored an 7.6 very standard pizza but the cheese to sauce ratio was spot on also the crust was very crunchy and delicious, Sicilian scored an 8.0 very good slice only critique I will give on the slice is it is very saucy, a little less sauce would have made it a perfect slice. Average is 7.8 and that’s a review!
stihlman5/13/21, 3:22 p.m.
Excellent! It has a nice firm crust and the right amount of sauce and cheese. The sauce also has a good flavor to it.
sunny.wu4/2/21, 11:05 p.m.
I tried them all so you wouldn't have to. Grandma - 8.2, very delightful and packs good tomato flavor in a thin package Vodka - 7.9, seems to use the same sauce as their amazing vodka pasta, my favorite of the triangles Margherita - 7.4, above average slice, great cheese on this one Plain - 7.2, great thin-ish slice, likely better than your local slice, but wouldn't go out of my way for it Pan - 4.8, heavy and doughy rather than thick and airy, I wouldn't get this one again Sicilian - 6.8, not sure about all the hype for this one, I've tried it 3 different times to be sure. There's a lot of sauce and dough. This one is fine for a square, but if it's the shape that you like, I'd rather get the grandma. Overall - 7.7, grab a grandma pie and try the amazing vodka pasta
jarettdesanti1/22/21, 2:51 a.m.
Umberto’s pizzeria Rating - 7.6 Decent pizza. Decent cheese and sauce.
carminedg1/16/21, 1:21 a.m.
Buffalo chicken. A little dry. I like my Buffalo chicken pizza with a white sauce. Great undercarriage
jbrancs1/7/21, 8:36 p.m.
This place is iconic, not to mention they gave me an extra slice. Some of the best sicilian around, the restaurant is great too!