Hands down best Sicilian slice you will find. Perfect crunch and not too much dough like many places. Sauce has a different tang then most and a bit of a bite. The rest is solid as well
frank.reese5/19/23, 4:55 p.m.
Big slices. A tad greasy. But amazing taste. Great crunch. Great undercarriage. Zero flop. The original Umbertos delivers. Get here if you can.
duncan.lundy5/11/23, 4:29 a.m.
This pizza was great- both the regular and the Sicilian. Buy these two roasted slices in my picture were what I got when I asked for them “not too hot”. If fairness, the water was pretty clueless altogether.
sam.kahane5/6/23, 7:51 p.m.
Wouldn’t plan my day around it - in fact, I’d hold my hunger and drive the hour to Little Vincent’s. Sauce was sour, cheese was soupy, and the medley of different slices helped in no way. Crust was the best part, and if I had to choose - go Sicilian
jessejamesrobo1/28/23, 5:03 p.m.
Good pizza. Went with the Sicilian as per the advice on here. Crust is awesome. Sauce could use some more flavor but all in all, excellent spot.
brian_f1/27/23, 6:26 p.m.
Previously had the Sicilian which I gave a 8.3 and in retrospect was too high. The grandma is by far the better pizza across all categories
anthony.cammarata12/26/22, 5:45 p.m.
Definitely one of Long island's best. Cooked crisp to perfection with the right blend of ingredient in the sauce making it almost homemade. The cheese was evenly spread making every bite a delight.
mdn25011/21/22, 11:38 p.m.
Definitely get the sicilian. Perfect crisp and a little airy center with great flavor and ratio of cheese.
tkori10/1/22, 10:55 p.m.
I have eaten both types of pies at this place. The Sicilian is the best I’ve ever eaten. I have not been able to eat a Sicilian pie anywhere else since I’ve been here. I actually crave it. Every time I fly to New York this is a must go to as well as John’s. That dough is so good, and you will find nothing like it anywhere else.
joe.pizza18/15/22, 5:28 p.m.
Both the regular slice and Sicilian are better than average. Good solid pizza.
lefty19707/28/22, 10:37 p.m.
Sicilian slices, far superior to the regular Neopolitan-style. Good crunch, nicely browned indercarriage. Great cheese/sauce/toppings ratio. Pro tip - get a side of their homemade meatballs, too.
tbocchino947/13/22, 5:36 p.m.
Not enough sauce the ratio is off. Great crisp and crust. Sicilian is a 9 easy so good
chris.pistorio5/24/22, 11:20 p.m.
Very good. Sauce was perfect combo of sweet and tangy. Pepperoni was good but a little thin, didn’t taste it. Better pepperoni would put it in 9s!
j.r744/25/22, 6:14 p.m.
Magnificent slice of pizza! Extra crispy crust with a flop that is nonexistent. When the man behind the counter says “and for you boss” you know your in for a treat.
philip.rapaglia13/27/22, 11:57 p.m.
Amazing thin slice with a nice crunch and just the right amount of cheese 🙏🏼. The sauce in the pizza is also just splendid the way the flavor burst in your mouth. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!!😋