andy.luca6/2/20, 12:38 a.m.
One of the best square slices I’ve ever had in my life. Very delicious. Great sauce, good crust, solid cheese.
mike.feigofsky5/28/20, 5:34 p.m.
Beautiful crunchy crust, moderate layer of stringy mozzarella, good flavored sauce.
billy.fryer2/29/20, 1:34 a.m.
It’s a great go to pizza, can definitely eat it at least once a week.
charles.tetro2/25/20, 1:49 a.m.
Best grandma pizza on LI (& the original) - 9.0, best Sicilian pizza in NY - 8.8, deep dish pan pizza - 8.6, and regular slice pizza - 7.6.
r2rich2/22/20, 12:48 p.m.
Ahhh, the gold standard. El Prez says you travel for anything in the 8’s, I moved from NY a few years ago, whenever I return, or when I bring work friends to NY, we head from JFK to NHP (New Hyde Park). This place is a landmark. Try getting in here for pizza during a Friday in Lent... Everything about Umberto’s is great, pizza, entrees, even desserts. After having Sicilian pizza here, it’s tough to compare anything else. I agree with Dave, regular is just above satisfactory, that’s the review...
sgt.pizza2/20/20, 5:58 p.m.
Regular: that's as good as it gets for a classic NY slice a little grease and all flavor 8.9 Sicilan: cooked perfect and full of flavor. 9 1 Grandma: it's just perfect you have to see for yourself the is without a doubt the best grandma in NY. 9.5
carmine.masullo2/17/20, 2:34 a.m.
very good sicilians but would i travel for it no..el president rating i think is way high..
chris.janusas2/14/20, 2:40 a.m.
Fantastic sicilian slice. Great consistent bread, great sauce, adequate cheese. A must have slice.
adrian.sharoyan2/9/20, 11:50 p.m.
Legit Sicilian, might be my favorite I’ve had. The margherita has a great crisp as well. Strong sauce.
hoe4pizza2/6/20, 4:36 a.m.
Square slices are better than the regular. Sauce is sweeter. Regular is still decent. Definitely one of my favorite spots.
kevin.o'connor51/26/20, 3:09 a.m.
Very good sauce but a bit too much cheese and grease. But overall a very good slice
hirtlocker1/12/20, 3:06 a.m.
Sicilian pie - love how the sauce and cheese s spread out and uneven, delicious tangy sauce and perfect crunch underneath, best Sicilian I've ever had!
michael.morrone11/10/20, 5:18 p.m.
Extremely crispy and thin. Loved the sauce had a nice tang. My favorite pizza. I traveled 45 mins for this and it was worth it.
nickyjbones1/2/20, 10:52 p.m.
Perhaps the high expectations hurt my view, but I was expecting to be blown away. You can win me over with a nice crust and the cheese and sauce was the best part!
laurence.tract12/29/19, 12:43 p.m.
Ehh- very basic. House salad simple lettuce and tomato. My appetizer. My wife had it for Main with salmon. A couple of tiny pieces. Since I had my kids with me had a large pie. Half buffalo chicken half peppers and mushrooms. On pepper/mush side- Sauce was very light and thin. No discernible flavor. Likewise thin layer of cheese - no flavor jumping out at me- all I got out of slice was crunch from crust and flavor of green pepper. Yelp and one bite rating of 8.2 to 8.6 way off. Disappointed. Cost of pie $33. Plus I traveled 20 minutes to get to place. Would not come back unless I had a gift cert.