Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

The Sicilian is a 9.1 if it’s fresh out of the oven. The regular slice is at most a 7.5 out of the oven. First score for me over 9 so just understand I’m a tough grader. The Sicilian is that good!

Pretty good pie

Damn good pizza!!!

It’s good pizza. If it was my local spot, I would eat here. I’m not going to travel far for this.

Excellent crust great sauce

Calm

Really good sicilian slice definitely in the top 5 slices of sicilian I've had

Grandma Style was unreal.. Sauce is amazing!

On Dave’s recommendation I came here. Damn it was good. Regular slice was a perfect combo of great sauce and cheese. No flop, good crust! Sicilian was an 8.5.

Zero flop. Great LI slice. Tad greasy, but overall great pizza.

Absolutely PHeNNNoMMMeNNNaLLL!Authentic sauce, crispy crust, fresh cheese, and no flop!!!

Dont get the hype on this sicilian. It wasnt that good

The best Grandma’s slice around!

9.5 easy BEST SICILIAN ON THE PLANET ! Consistent every time !! Always crunchy , always fantastic , I leave 1/2 point open Incase god comes down himself and creates something ! My aunt drives a hour every Friday to take the pie home !! Sicilian ! Can’t beat it !!

FYI apparently you typically can’t get the pizza in the restaurant part but the pizzeria was full and the waiter was very accommodating. Grandma pie was great - good balance of ingredients and had a great crunch

Very sloppy pie. Cheese was very sloppy. Slice was tasty which salvaged the score but overall could have been much better.

Excellent Sicilian pizza

This review is for the Margherita. It’s an excellent slice. Great cheese and sauce. Was hyped up for the grandma but only would give it about an 8.3, about the same for the Sicilian.

Really like the Sicilian and Grandma slice too.

Solid but not crazy good