Vicini's New York City Pizzeria

Bit of flop. ‘Twas good

‘Twas delicious

By far the best pizza I’ve had on the west coast. Truly looks and tastes just like NYC pizza. As someone from the Northeast who is very familiar with NY style pizza, this is as good as it gets. Crispy crust, solid undercarriage with a bit of flop but the amazing cheese and sauce flavor makes up for that. A bit greasy as well but that’s just your typical NY style pizza. I got this pizza at #3 on my all-time pizza list and #1 on my west coast pizza list. Would highly recommend this place, especially if you’re from the east coast and you miss your really good NY style pizza places!

Samples several kinds of their pizza , for the recited the pepperoni pictured has hot honey on it and it's not all grease! I scored the unpictured vodka sauce cheese slice and it was spectacular. Flavorful thin crust, zero flop, perfect crunch with a beautiful under carriage that was baked to perfection. The sauce was zesty creamery. Cheese was perfect and not over cooked. I would recommend this to anyone passing Fairfield or looking to try a NY style over 8.0 pizza in the area.

As hood as a NY style pizza ur gona get on the west coast. Great char and chew, very high quali ingredients. As always order whole pies and well done for fair a review.

Firm crust, really good cheese. Between crust, cheese, sauce, I’m most attentive with the sauce. But the sauce doesn’t pop out here. Still, it’s good.

Good flop. Nice crunch. Little greasy.

A little floppy. Solid taste. Good crust.

How anybody rates this pizza under an 8 is beyond me!! Request well done get a little more char on there oh lawd worth every dollar!

Great pizza

This place is hit or miss. Definitely not NY quality or taste but the style is close enough. Overpriced for what you get.

As a plain cheese pie guy...this is very good especially for the bay area. Definitely reminds me of New York.

Recently moved from NJ. Best pizza in Fairfield/Vacaville area. No flop. Taste is familiar and takes me back to NJ. Crisp crust with black on the fingers. One bite everyone knows the rules.

Taste like Sbbaro

I’ve had better pies from this Joint. Very good pizza still. This particular pie the cheese is spot on. The crust doesn’t have the crunch you’re looking for. It gives you more of a soft chew. The sauce doesn’t quite have the tang I feel it needs but overall a very good pie. I will definitely update the score with another review next time I go because I know these guys can do better. They have don’t better in the past.

Solid pizza. Good looking inside. Pizza slice plentiful and filling. Try the garlic knots. Overall good slice, sauce is a little light.

Closest thing you’ll get to a NY style pizza...great big flop, huge flavor and crispy crust makes it fantastic. Only thing missing is a bit more zest on the sauce...best option in the north bay