Villa D' Carlo

Tasty pie.. pepperoni has a nice zip to it and crunchy all the way through. Ordered with extra sauce and was perfect. Would return if in area. Had the "snack" 9" pizza and was perfect amount for one person.

Late night pizza on way home from a basketball shootout in MKE. Really love the crust and crispness. Just really nothing else stood out for me. With Wells not far away it’s very hard to meet that standard. I like this pizza but it’s about a 7 for me.

Really solid pizza. Crust is thin and crunchy and the oven they use to cook it clearly has been seasoned over decades of use. Only issue I have is with the way they cut their onion/green pepper for toppings. Really wish it was thinly sliced veggies instead of a dice.

Great tavern pizza with a pasta sauce instead of traditional marinara. Great crisp! We ate it all.

This pie had the chance of being in the 8s just needed a little more sauce. Great crisp and crust with good flavor.

Solid pie