Villa Milano

Let me be clear, this pizza was really good. The regular slice had a great crunch and the flavors were all great. But the guy who helped me put the slices in the oven with his bare hands and took them out of the oven with his bare hands. There wasn’t a spatula in sight. Bad practice for a pizza place, especially from an older guy. They’d get a high 7 if it wasn’t for that.

Crisp cheesy tastey

Was in the area so gave it a shot. Love the guys in there. Sauce is different and very tasty. Grandma was great. Regular was average at best and nothing to write about.

Excellent pizza all around. Hits all the boxes and the best I’ve had on the island

Typical old school Italian pizza joint with pictures of all the famous Italian movie stars and musicians. Too bad their pizza just doesn’t measure up to all those pictures. Slices came out oily and had that oil tangy taste. Crust was on the lighter side, zero flop, but could have been well done to add to the taste. It’s not a terrible slice, but nothing to write home about. Enjoy!!

Regular was 3 napkin greasy . Nice sauce but very doughy Sicilian had a strange texture. Also doughy.

🍕🐀

Pretty floppy good taste though

I’m definitely biased, but I’ve been coming here for almost 20 years and it’s still my favorite place!

Buffalo chicken slice

Huge flop, marinara is a bit bland. Pretty doughy, if this had some more crisp i could see it in the mid 7s. A basic island slice. That’s a review Franklyn!

A good slice, a little greasy. Crisp with some flop, slightly sweet sauce with very gooey cheese and a doughy crisp crust.

Decently crisp but dry, tasteless crust. Decent, though unexceptional otherwise.

Decent football pizza. No flop which is good. A bit cheesy and oily but good overall.

High level pizza. Perfect blend of cheese to sauce ratio. Crust is on the money.

Saved the best for last. Crust and sauce were incredible, especially the sauce. Best slice on Plandome Road is Villa Milano.