whatispizza58/3/22, 7:16 p.m.
A quintessential slice place with long standing Italian goofiness and efficiency behind the pizza counter. This place was slammed at 11 am. There used to be a Weight Watchers next door in the 90s. My mom would always take us there after her class. I don’t know if the positioning was intentional or not but needless to say now there is a clothing store next door.
ahcurtis10/7/21, 3:50 a.m.
True pizzeria style, great guys behind the counter, get extra ice in your drink. Best in central Jersey
njbeachpizza5/1/20, 10:01 p.m.
Dough was bad. No rise. Very saucy which isn’t bad but pizza was not cooked enough to support.
chadt8/1/19, 1:41 a.m.
Little greasy, no flop, not crispy enough in my opinion but good sauce and cheese, ok crust
jrzanyc7/22/19, 12:29 a.m.
OK so here it goes. The funny thing about doing a review is sometimes you walk into a place and a slice is good or decent and sometimes you go in there for a second or third time and not so much. This is the case today. So I’ve had villa a couple times because it’s close and local. It never blew me away but for this part of jersey it was edible. Well unfortunately for them today is the review and this is that other time.. I’ll start with a somewhat positive. The DO towards the back end of a slice had a nice taste I was pretty crispy. What I look for in a run-of-the-mill pizza dough. I know I’m not going to get extraordinary in the middle of Jersey so ideal. Towards the end of the slice what a horrible flop. Not a New York flop a jersey junk flop. The edge was soaked with a mixture of runny tomato sauce , Grease, and underwhelming cheese. The sauce was not so good. Tasted like a squash tomato with absolutely no flavor. I was hoping for a little bit more than that. The cheese, tasted like the cheaper out this month, i’ve also tasted better quality cheese from them. So I don’t know maybe it’s on the down slide from average. And I’m saying average for the middle of Jersey which is not saying much. Sorry to say you won’t see me here again. 5.2 that’s the review
project_lifted7/13/19, 11:42 p.m.
Not bad at all. Flop but not crazy. Crust is crispy all the way threw I prefer crisp outside soft inside. Cheese and sauce are not great but above average. Overall best pizza I’ve had so far in Middletown area
kingal5/11/19, 3:24 p.m.
Like the place , average pie, sauce was decent , cheese was below average ..haven’t been here in a while but it’s like remembered
barberovdayear4/29/19, 5:43 p.m.
Good slice, i like the sauce, the crust had a nice crisp. A bit too greasy but overall a 7.2
dean.faro11/5/18, 12:30 a.m.
Crust was a little too crispy. Cheese was melted perfectly. Sauce was distributed evenly throughout the slice.