Very solid slice. Slight flop, crisp crust, good amount of cheese, and great sauce.
a.jonze3/12/21, 2:34 a.m.
Individual neopolitan slices are big. My score is more of an all-around rating. While the neopolitan slice is probably more like a 7.2 (tasty sauce, not too much flop, but a bit heavy), the Grandma's slices are a solid 8.0-8.5+ all day long. They are very consistent, where you pretty much get the same slice or pie every time, cooked the same, tastes the same, etc. The dinners are very good too, a solid 8 on that front as well. And great service too. Definitely in the top 3 pizzerias on hwy 35 between Hazlet and Red Bank.
jrzanyc7/25/20, 8:13 p.m.
Qaurentine Review time..... here in Middletown nj.... I looked at the reviews prior to my review and I must have gotten lucky because I was impressed. And I don’t impress easily but I gotta judge by the slice and the one I got was very good... no flip.. great quality cheese, and a tasty sauce... one knock would be that it needed a little more sauce.. the crust was crispy throughout and nice and thin .... this would win my football slice award thus far.... 8.1 that’s the score... I would hope that I could return and get the same slice despite the previous scores and pictures... 8.1!
nyflop943/20/20, 11:18 p.m.
Pretty floppy pizza. The sauce was meh. Crust was kinda amateur. If ur gonna go to villa I suggest going for the grandma pie instead.
mayorblueberryjerry12/14/19, 9:19 p.m.
Crust was great the bottom was cooked right but lacks taste more flavor but a good slice for on the go
roy.erickson3/20/19, 9:32 p.m.
Decent crisp, solid zest with the sauce, almost perfect cheese.cant go wrong here
maureen.reilly10/26/18, 11:26 p.m.
Cheese has perfect amount of stretch and sauce is sweet yet savory 👌🏼