Village Square Pizza - West Village

The Sicilian pizza was delicious. Great sauce.

Maybe I got the wrong slice, but it was inedible garlicky. Had to toss it after 2 bites. Really disliked it. Promising crust though. I’ll try it again.

Great crust. Good overall slice. New York flop.

I would come here again if I was back NYC. The crisp no flop cheese slice and slightly spicy pepperoni, with the perfect amount of marinara.

Excellent slice - They are know for their square slices. Great sauce, cheese was fresh and the crust has a nice crunch. Dave should definitely check this place out.

only thing that could have gotten it to the 10.0 is if Dave Portney fed it to me

First time tryin a hot honey roni and I see why people could like this it’s not for me but I did enjoy it as a change of pace. Crispy underneath nice cheese and zingy sauce to go with the spicy roni and the hot honey to balance it out. If this is your thing it’s up there big time. Great staff and joint too!

Best square slices in the city

Great crisp and undercarriage. Little oily/greasy on top.

Little bland, but good cheese

Not bad. Crispy pepperoni and crust. Lacks flavor compared to PSP