Deep dish would be the way to go on this one. Flavor is balanced right. Sweeter sauce. Bottom of crust is browned which is good. Thin slice is average. Score is for the deep dish
kevin.brecht1/14/21, 7:09 p.m.
Sorry, forgot about the picture until I demolished half that pizza. Dave was spot on in his review. This is the epitome of bar pizza. Perfect crust to cheese to sauce It's a topping ratio. Good sauce. Good cheese. Very basic and very good.
frattydaddy1/8/21, 6:21 p.m.
Sauce is fucking delicious, super tangy and full of spices, kind of a greasefest, but can’t really complain at about $2 a slice, pretty solid option for Cleveland.
ice_cream_pusha9/30/20, 4:17 p.m.
Good ingredients & great crust. The stuffed pizza is the bees knees!
bigmo29711/25/19, 4:29 p.m.
$2.25 slice I'd pay $5 for! Great flop' Mason Rudolph type of flop! #freegarret 8.1 Great crunch for midwest pizza!
134 views•10 likes
frank.strama11/11/19, 5:29 p.m.
Crunchy thin crust with tons of flop, a nice bite from the sauce and well distributed stringy cheese. Great service Great pizza
ken.lewis8/14/19, 3:50 p.m.
Crispy crust! several different options, I had a slice of cheese and a slice of Pepperoni, must have if visiting Cleveland! Very friendly staff!
phillypies8/5/19, 8:01 p.m.
Pretty basic pie. Really no flavor here - really good crisp and no flop, but otherwise it was uninteresting. One of the better rated places down town so i had high hopes, but the community seems a little high. Gonna need to get back to philly for some better pizza. Bonus reviews - plain Sicilian: 6.7/pepperoni - 7.3
casey.wright17/19/19, 10:22 p.m.
YOU DONE MESSED UP A- ARON!!! An authentic New York slice in downtown Cleveland. Thin crust, just the right amount of sauce and cheese. More importantly cooked to the correct crisp! Now march down to O'Shag-Hennessey's office and explain to him exactly what you did?
steavis7677/17/19, 5:30 p.m.
Sauce and cheese was sort of an odd mix but the taste was good. Crispy crust was the best part.
thomas.walker37/9/19, 6:59 p.m.
Nice shop with many different choices. Good location near Rocket Mortgage Field house and Progressive. I had the thin crust with pepperoni. I give the sauce an A, the cheese C+, and the crust B.
joe.kneebusch7/9/19, 6:59 p.m.
Very hot at first so have to let it cool for a little. Very crunchy and no flop. The sauce is also very good.
grampil6/25/19, 10:08 p.m.
Hot & crispy right out of the oven. Would’ve like a bit more sauce.
pat.ahern6/24/19, 8:55 p.m.
Best Pie in the country, the two owners are closet nice guys. The pie is epic. The crust perfect, sauce and cheese perfect meld. Dave should hit the joint during the MLB Allstar game next month.
brodie.wolf3/22/19, 5:08 p.m.
Great sauce and cheese. Great crisp with slight flop. Solid Neapolitan
brandon.bugbee2/28/19, 4:44 a.m.
Ok two diff slices here. On the left was cheese Neapolitan cheese the right was Chicago deep dish cheese. So the neap was the one I’m giving a 7.0 to. It tasted good. It was a little weird because it almost seemed like the cheese and sauce were one but it was something I got over quickly. The crust was by far the best part of the pizza. Cooked perfectly and had a magnificent crunch. Definitely why it got the seven instead of a six something. Now the Chicago was in my opinion better, wasn’t quite as sloppy and yet again with even more crust it was cooked to perfection. I’d say 7.5 for the deep dish. All around solid slices here. Also was nice that they sold by the slice.