Vincenza's Pizzeria

Not good. Better options around

Solid slice, nice tang in the sauce, crispy bottom and good crust.

Best pizza around. Crisp, not too oily, great ingredients, great taste.

Nasty taste nasty sauce very disappointing since it looked good, it’s like a nasty little ceasers sauce taste I actually couldn’t even finish the slice it was that bad of a flavor first time for everything I guess

Had some good crust! A bunch of McFarland flop! Sauce and cheese were ok. 6.6

Super floppy, but it has great flavor all around. Very good slice.

Pretty good slice. If it wasn’t so expensive I’d come here a lot more

Definitely worth seeking out. Sauce has a unique flavor, wish there was more on the slice. Crust is just about perfect, great crunch but not cracker thin. Little too much grease or well this is in the mid 8’s.

Really good. Thin slices. Good ingredients. Good bite (once I let the slices cool off). Little too much grease which kept it out of the 8's.

Pepperoni slices. Super greasy, half the slice falls off on the flop. Sauce is a little sweet but good. The cheese is great quality. Closest combo I have seen to NY. Crust is good not great. Pepperoni is oversized but still good. Gotta say this is the best slice I have encountered here in the ATL area. Disclaimer: born and raised in NYC so all raitings are compared to NY style.

A nice sized slice. Good cheese to sauce to bread ratio. A little greasy on top, but the bottom is cooked nicely. A little more flop than I'd like. Crust is nice and flaky but could use a little more flavor. I would get this pizza again, but might request it a little more "well done."

Tasty reheated slice.

Very good pizza. Sweet tangy sauce and crispy bite.

Got a slice of both the thin crust and the Sicilian. Both were excellent. By far the best pizza in 10-15 square miles, maybe more. Our new go to place for pizza. Same owners a BB’s bagels, they are New Yorkers transplanted to GA and it shows. You will not be disappointed. I am from the New Haven area and although it’s new haven style it gets me just as excited.

Actual NY style in GA, best pizza in the area

Football pizza, crust is crisp, sauce was good but could have used more... cheese was just ok