Vito's Slices and Ices

Would be even better fresh cooked

Start by saying hard to grade this place without fresh pies. Very cool old school vibe. Can totally see them having a core base of repeat customers. However seems like they’re known for circles but I liked their grandma slice better. Circle a little greasy for my preference. No stand out ingredient. Usually cheese little more flair with that much grease. Sauce a bit underwhelming. Cooked well though. Would try again on full fresh pie

Great crispy crust, cheese is a bit heavy but the sauce is amazing. Next time I’d go with a whole pie cuz fresher and prob cheese wouldn’t have set up as much. Great slices tho!

Really good overall. A lot of cheese but I actually enjoyed it. There was enough sauce to support all the cheese which didn't make the cheese overbearing. The crust was nice and fluffy inside and crisp outside. I wish the undercarriage was a little crispier to support everything going on top but overall great taste. I will be back!

Good traditional old school slice on Ninth Ave. Great taste. A little flop but worth it because of the taste. Great find!

Pepperoni was absolutely amazing

Vito’s fire

Review 476. Large crisp crust. Thin slice very floppy a bit greasy. Nice flavor to sauce but where is the cheese? Undercarriage was ok.this would be maybe just something to hold you over to dinner $4.00 needs more cheese

Plain slice was a lil bland…pepperoni was really good…

Overall a strong slice. Too much flop on the dough and there was not much going on with its overall taste. Good cheese and sauce.

little saucy for me, not enough cheese. sauce flavor pretty good aswell as the crust. the white slice is better than the cheese imo

First of new york ‘24 trip. Love the pepperoni, quite a lot of flop and grease but those are just pluses!

Underrated + offer a gluten free slice which is a rarity

Goated tier