Wayne Ale House & Pizza

I wish there was more sauce

Very good taste! Good crisp! Crust was a bit uneven… thicker on one side than the other. The thinner side was very chewy and cramped my jaw after 2 pcs.

All the pies with sauce were solid, some basil tossed on, good ingredients all around. Toppings were on lesser side but adequate for me. Very solid crunch on the dough. Tavern grandma special was solid too. Would skip the white pie.

This pizza dominates. Blown away was only expecting high 7s low 8s but I all in on over a 9!

Zero flop for foot long slice is impressive to say the least, tangy sauce and great crust

Pleasantly surprised with this one. Sauce on top is a nice touch. Nice parm crust. Not a huge semolina guy, but this works for the product. Will gladly eat time and time again

The best part is definitely the crust. Nice and crispy for sure. I’m not a fun fan of the spiral sauce pattern. It leads to having bites that all sauce and then all cheese. Still a good slice

Black and burnt on the under side and crust, tasted like burnt bacon. Cheese and sauce were good.

I definitely know why Dave gave it a 7.6. The 24 inch pie is thick football pizza that’s the bad! The good part is the taste, excellent sauce, and the sauce to cheese ratio is nailed. It’s Perfectly cooked as well. Not my type of pizza, not a bar pie by any means. But tasty.

This might be the best pizza we ever had! On top of the size of the pies - delicious sauce and tasty crust! Perfection!!

Just like the Round Pie Pizza Company chain (old bridge, freehold, matawan), thin crust, semolina or corn meal undercarriage, san marzano tomato sauce, low moisture Mozzarella, with fresh basil. Is it worth driving an hour, no, but if in the area (30 min) yes worth a try. Great beer as a bonus, plus can watch football! Funny, they have a sign on every table “Let's get Dave Portnoy here!” C’mon Dave give them a review Service was excellent, very attentive!

Portnoy worthy of trying !

Delicious! Dave…you need to try it!

Best well done thin crispy plain pizza I’ve ever had 🍕

This is by far the best pizza I have ever had. Not only is it great, the pie size is unreal in todays “less for more”. A pizza game changer!!!

My family’s favorite pizza. We rate it higher than any of the New Haven places and any other places in NJ/NY. The pizzas are huge, crispy, and delicious every single time. Other menu items are also fantastic though we’ve mainly stuck to the wings - they’re oven roasted and every bit as good as any wings I’ve had except for Duff’s in Buffalo.

Four of us ordered the big pizza and only ate half. The owner Rob told us the trick to reheat it back at home. Love this Pizza!