Order now on Slice
Order Westbrook Pizzeria
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
About Westbrook Pizzeria
31 Yelp Reviews
bigdaddytom8710/20/22, 10:00 p.m.
Not too bad, just about middle of the road quality. Sauce is a bit sweet but in need of oregano and garlic, has flop and lacks crisp, but I've had worse. Actual score was 6.1 but I give an 0.2 bonus for the slice being only $3.00 and another 0.2 bonus for being next to a Carvel.
cjaquilino9/26/22, 2:28 a.m.
Perfectly fine football pizza. This is where Planet Fitness (Peekskill) got it's pizza from for it's monthly pizza day, which stopped since the pandemic. I see people trashed this pizza here. But I decide to get a bunch (5 for $4.99) of end of the night slices from them on Too Good To Go—they were all good. I felt better than Stella's at the edge of Putnam Valley. Medium thin, medium brown bake, average aeration type crust deal. No flop. But it's a crust you won't bother eating once you get to the cornicione. Cheese-sauce ratio was fine. Obviously tilted toward the cheese. Whole milk low moisture mozzarella, sauce spread almost the full way up to the end crust, which is fairly minimal. Sauce is medium chunky not loose. Oregano spiked and fairly salted. Definitely savory rather than naturally sweet. I just find this pizza inoffensive. I've yet to try Nonna's Cortlandt/Put Valley. I've found them all to be different. But if I lived this side of Peekskill/Cortlandt, I'd go Amici's. But it's all preference. Yes, I always go for plains. But good pepperoni slice, sausage and peppers slice, and chicken Parm slice. I don't go for specialty stuff. This is all high 6-low 7s in my book.
mr.mozzerella12/22/19, 10:02 p.m.
This is one of the weirdest slices I’ve ever had. The slice is very big. The cheese is soupy and the sauce taste like it was poured straight out of a can from a dollar store. The crust was pretty thick and it tasted like raw whole wheat flour. The mozzarella was by far the highlight of the experience. It’s like they spent all of the money on good mozzarella, big screen tv’s, uniforms and forgot about the sauce and dough. This is a little above average slice.
bill.gallagher4/18/19, 1:04 a.m.
Your pretty average football pizza. Sauce was decent, crust was somewhat thin but could have been a little more crispy.
ryanallday4/14/19, 12:24 a.m.
As basic as pizza gets. The dough is an odd consistency almost like whole wheat. Idk.
pizzascientist11/5/18, 6:41 p.m.
Well above average football pizza. Pretty greasy, but for $2 hard to argue.