One Bite App | Pizza Review App by Barstool Sports
Download
Home
Top Restaurants
Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Sister Bay

Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Sister Bay

10677 North Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay, Wisconsin
32 views•5 likes
jackcooney12 on One Bite Pizza App

jackcooney12

9/3/18 1:55 AM

Pizza Review
lue.cambell9/13/25, 6:30 p.m.
Pizza review

6.9

Great place. Pizza is good not great. I would recommend this place for the atmosphere and vibes as much as the pizza.
0 likes
Pizza Review
robert.geiger9/6/25, 2:43 a.m.
Pizza review

7.1

Is it good? Yes. Could’ve they cooked my pizza a little longer? Yes. Was the sauce phenomenal? YES!
0 likes
Pizza Review
liam.bruce6/25/25, 12:34 a.m.
Pizza review

8.1

I have already reviewed the location in Fish Creek, and was excited to try it again after a rather underwhelming first review. This time, however, it is very good. I ordered the same thing, but ordered the za well done. Not only do I feel the quality is better on this pizza, but the location itself was awesome too. This location is bigger, and the service was speedy. Enough about the location, let’s get back to the pizza. The crust was well done, so it was better than the first time. The cheese and sauce also tasted a bit better than the first time. The one complaint I would say is that the crust towards the middle and outwards to the end of the crust is not crunchy. That must be a dough problem, but will not take anything away because of it. Overall excellent pizza and service. I do declare 8.1 that’s the review
0 likes
Pizza Review
oliverb9206/23/25, 5:46 p.m.
Pizza review

6.9

Good, nothing spectacular
0 likes
Pizza Review
coleclark6/10/25, 3:12 a.m.
Pizza review

8.7

50% Hot Honey Pepperoni, 50% Pesto Sausage Tomato, 100% delicious #BNCTRT2025
1 like
Pizza Review
jack.bruce35/26/25, 11:11 p.m.
Pizza review

7.6

This is very good pizza. The crust is great, the toppings are good although they overdid the sausage just a bit. The flaws come down to it being a little greasy, and the cheese was pretty bland. It’s in a very touristy area, so do with that information what you will. Overall very good pizza, would definitely recommend!
0 likes
Pizza Review
alrighteddy5/21/25, 11:21 p.m.
Pizza review

7.8

Solid Pizza. It’s a little floppy, but the crust is awesome. Wood fired pizza. Get the supreme!
0 likes
Pizza Review
sarah.martin412/21/24, 9:31 p.m.
Pizza review

5.0

Rocks
0 likes
Pizza Review
sam_the_man.7/26/24, 4:28 p.m.
Pizza review

5.8

Very soft, changed owners since last year, not as good, cheese is very strong, better Cold.
1 like
Pizza Review
waerdags2/3/24, 11:12 p.m.
Pizza review

8.1

1 like
Pizza Review
tyler.voorhees1/1/24, 12:04 a.m.
Pizza review

8.2

0 likes
Pizza Review
kaymrt12/31/23, 11:59 p.m.
Pizza review

8.0

0 likes
Pizza Review
tera.holmes12/15/23, 10:47 p.m.
Pizza review

7.9

Delicious… crispy crust that holds up well. Great texture and crisp veggies with the toppings. The sauce is out of this world. Bought some sauce to bring home!
0 likes
Pizza Review
trever.schoenfeld10/21/23, 5:02 p.m.
Pizza review

8.7

Very good but it was not well cut and the toppings don’t stay on. Crust is delicious!
0 likes
Pizza Review
liv_499/9/23, 7:31 p.m.
Pizza review

7.1

this place looked great on the inside and out outstanding location family friendly and good pizza got cold fast and crust was pretty ok
1 like
Pizza Review
nfro248/20/23, 12:58 p.m.
Pizza review

7.5

When we come to DC, we have to stop by wild tomato! Never dissapoints!
1 like
Pizza Review
lillie.hanto7/9/23, 2:57 a.m.
Pizza review

6.8

0 likes
Pizza Review
mattessman8/6/22, 4:50 p.m.
Pizza review

7.8

Delicious.
0 likes
Pizza Review
mike.brookins7/20/22, 12:54 a.m.
Pizza review

6.7

Created a Pepperoni Sausage and Jalapeño plus one black olive. Sausage tasted like papa johns plus there was too mush flop. Great atmosphere.
0 likes
Pizza Review
calee26622/12/21, 1:44 p.m.
Pizza review

7.9

Great pizza. Great beer. Great location. Easily the best pizza on the peninsula!
0 likes
Pizza Review
matthew.bauknecht9/2/20, 8:55 p.m.
Pizza review

7.7

Crust could be a little crispier. Otherwise best pizza in Door County.
0 likes
Pizza Review
andrew.leech8/29/20, 10:14 p.m.
Pizza review

8.1

Good crisp good nice tang to the sauce best pizza to date
1 like
Pizza Review
andrew.vescio8/5/20, 5:11 p.m.
Pizza review

7.8

Great pizza one of the go two places! A little floppy.
1 like
Pizza Review
bob.mccoy7/31/20, 8:00 p.m.
Pizza review

7.3

0 likes
Pizza Review
isaiah.butler7/16/20, 11:23 p.m.
Pizza review

7.7

Wood fire oven. Sauce is excellent. Crust is light and a bit on the doughy side. Basil could’ve been better.
0 likes
(920) 854-4685
10677 North Bay Shore Drive
Sister Bay, Wisconsin 54234
Something not look right?
Suggest an Edit
Barstool Bets - Barstool Gambling
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

© 2026 Barstool Sports. All rights reserved.

Terms of UsePrivacy PolicyContent PolicyContact UsApp Support