Williamsburg Pizza

HUGE classic ny style football slices that were pretty great. Nice and thin with 0 flop and a near perfect crunch to it. Maybe slightly too crunchy but that’s nit picking to be honest. Slightly over greasy and over salted but barely. This is basically as good of a football pizza as it gets

Enjoyed the pepperoni more than the regular. Crust is pretty solid and a nice crunch to the slice. The pepperoni was a bit greasy but a good greasy if you know what I mean.

Think Dave nailed it here with his score. SOLID football slice right here.... everything is very good about this slice, sauce, cheese, ratio. Crispier and it’s maybe a 9... great slice.

So freaking good. Nice thick pizza with a great sauce

Very Good Pie

Tasty

Absolutely amazing pie. Next level NY pizza.

When I opened up the box, I didn’t like the looks of it...and after I took a bite, I didn’t care for the taste either. Not sure what happened here...this pizza doesn’t look like any of the other pies I’ve seen reviewed here. This pie had a very similar taste to Pizza Time (the Kosher Pizza) in Brooklyn which I thought was vile. The cheese did not have a pleasant taste, almost as if it was expired. The sauce was pasty and not very flavorful at all. The dough felt more stale than crispy and was incredibly bland. I don’t know if this was just an “off night” for this joint or what but I’m being very generous with my 6.6 score.

The square slice is undercooked. The plain is solid, the sauce is like a paste on the dough, also very heavy on the oregano

This Review is for the one 84 street and 2 ave In Manhattan.

Good standard slice. Nothing spectacular though.

Good lookin slice, great crunch, great cheese, overall great pizza

Stop 2 - super thin, very crispy crust on both styles - back to the golden slice - cheese-sauce ratio good , but just average flavor for me - grandma slice is the go to here - grandma I give a 7.9... golden slice -

Very solid slice! A beautiful kiss of a sweet yet savoury sauce , coated with an average layer of cheese,very nice crunch to the base and edible crust

Forgot to take a pic just like my ex-wife “forgot” to show up to our family photo three years in a row. Not great.

Solid crunch, good sauce

Very overrated! Nothing special about this slice. I find it insulting Dave gave this a higher score than L&B’s

Walnut, Pecan, Apple Ate a gold medal slice too

Decent grandma slice

got a notification on one bite while driving by. its a solid slice. dough is very good but slice was sitting for a while. i think dave missed mark on this one , its ok but wont be back.