Think Dave nailed it here with his score. SOLID football slice right here.... everything is very good about this slice, sauce, cheese, ratio. Crispier and it’s maybe a 9... great slice.
kirsch10/27/20, 12:40 a.m.
Good football pizza: heavy on the oregano but too light/not enough flavor in the sauce to go into the 8s
funky.pizza.lover10/24/20, 9:15 p.m.
Excellent undercarriage; taste is excellent (cheese, sauce, crust and tomatoes); many, many good flavor options; top 10 pizza in NYC.
jason.lipto9/17/20, 5:34 p.m.
Forgot to take a photo lol. I love this place! The margherita and cheese slices are so bomb. I don’t love the grandma but many others do.
mark.rada9/7/20, 8:42 p.m.
Flavourful sauce without being salty or acidic. Cheese a bit oily. Good crust.
calimondi7/26/20, 8:40 p.m.
Such a good slice! Honestly their Sicilian slice might be my favorite though. Sauce 👌🏻 cheese 👌🏻 crisp crust 👌🏻
forgetaboutit6/26/20, 12:25 a.m.
Solid tasty slice! Floppy but crunchy. Good cheese tasty slice, good crust.. very regular above average slice.. am i driving to brooklyn from NJ like ill drive to queens for pizza from sLICe? No, but if im in the area im definitely grabbing a pie to bring home.. youKnowWaddaMean?? 7.4 Franky! Badaboom! Thats a review
jcaputo325/25/20, 8:32 p.m.
HUGE classic ny style football slices that were pretty great. Nice and thin with 0 flop and a near perfect crunch to it. Maybe slightly too crunchy but that’s nit picking to be honest. Slightly over greasy and over salted but barely. This is basically as good of a football pizza as it gets
domenico.cusumano4/7/20, 2:18 a.m.
Enjoyed the pepperoni more than the regular. Crust is pretty solid and a nice crunch to the slice. The pepperoni was a bit greasy but a good greasy if you know what I mean.
ryan.rutherford3/10/20, 7:56 a.m.
When I opened up the box, I didn’t like the looks of it...and after I took a bite, I didn’t care for the taste either. Not sure what happened here...this pizza doesn’t look like any of the other pies I’ve seen reviewed here. This pie had a very similar taste to Pizza Time (the Kosher Pizza) in Brooklyn which I thought was vile. The cheese did not have a pleasant taste, almost as if it was expired. The sauce was pasty and not very flavorful at all. The dough felt more stale than crispy and was incredibly bland. I don’t know if this was just an “off night” for this joint or what but I’m being very generous with my 6.6 score.
craig.mcgrath3/10/20, 1:43 a.m.
The square slice is undercooked. The plain is solid, the sauce is like a paste on the dough, also very heavy on the oregano
sorryiamlactose3/5/20, 11:12 p.m.
This Review is for the one 84 street and 2 ave In Manhattan.