Average. But not bad. Could you some more flavorful sauce and dough. Cheese was good. Don’t really need to try again though
ecao11/15/20, 3:10 a.m.
cheese slice: cheese just melted in your mouth; decent quality cheese, but not exceptional; good dough; good crisp, above standard for a NY slice; good amount of oil; overall, nice firm, crispy, satisfying NY slice grandma slice: a bit of an overwhelming garlic flavor at the beginning, but got better; very good crisp; basil was a good (and necessary) addition; perhaps a tad bit more oily than I would've liked; sauce/cheese distributed well (8.2/10)
guy.fernando2/27/20, 6:02 p.m.
This is mediocre ‘zza. Yeah, sure, the crunch is *good*, but everything else is mediocre. No New York Flop (NYF), boring sauce and tasteless cheese. The crust is fine, I guess. It’s a slightly above average pizza...but if you’re in New York City in the first place, don’t go here. The price ($3.25 per) does not warrant the slice.
bob.barker86/27/19, 4:09 p.m.
It was dry, but still had a little pizzazz. If you’re in the neighborhood, then it’s decent. Wouldn’t travel though.
parker.van dorn6/23/19, 6:14 a.m.
Ok pizza, too much sauce, cheese and was mediocre. Not bad, but not stellar
sal.greco5/14/19, 2:43 p.m.
This place is awesome! I haven’t been to the original location but this is the same owner. The grandma slice is out of this world also, one of the best I’ve ever had and u fortunately The President never grades anything other then the regular slices, in this case the “ Brooklyn “ slice is a solid 7.9
jp18135/11/19, 10:53 p.m.
Not your classic cheese pie but a great mix up nonetheless. Tried a “Grandma” style pizza. It was delicious. A bit over cooked would have loved it in the oven for a couple minutes less. The imgredients were fresh and crust was crispy just needed to not overcook that cheese so much and we’d be in the 8 range. Good pie overall, g knots were solid as well.
waviec3/18/19, 6:55 a.m.
The sauce had a weird taste and the slice was really salty Frankie. That’s a review
haisai052612/6/18, 9:53 p.m.
Crispy crust, sauce bland no real taste, cheese is awesome and tasty!