Williamsburg Pizza

Grandma pie from last night was incredible. Crispy, awesome sauce, and perfect amount of cheese and basil.

Thin, crispy, but could use more flavor in the sauce

A very solid football pizza. Pretty unique crust thats fluffy yet crispy at the same time. Sauce and cheese are both very good. Sauce is slightly on the sweet side with some herbs mixed in there. Almost gave it a rookie 8.0.

Doing my part for national pizza day. Does it need more pep cups? Negative. It’s loaded up. NY flop? Yes. Crust? Excellent. More sauce? Maybe.

Plain slice was a solid 8.2 Bacon apple slice was a 9.5

Super hot! Fresh slice straight out the oven. It’s very tasty, good sauce, great cheese, very flavorful.

Probably one of the best straight forward classic New York slices. Just great and classic all around. Good cheese, good crust, good sauce. I really enjoyed it. Would definitely go back.

Grandma slice was amazing, pepperoni slice had great flavor, cheese slice was amazing, sauce heavy on the cheese slice but the sauce was delicious

It’s more than just football pizza. It’s damn good.

Fantastic. Crust is crsipy af though lacking in flavor. Sauce and cheese are incredible though. Grandma pepperoni is in the mid 9's. Garlic knot also at least a 9.1.

Amazing pepperoni

Great slice. Not much flop.

Plain slice was great. Liked the Grandma slice too (but oily). Loved the truffle slice.

Solid structure, great sauce, good cheese. Little oily.

Average slice. In the 8s is way too high. Too doughy. A solid slice but nothing more. I was disappointed and had higher hopes after Dave’s review.

Love the crunch on the square.

Very good slice, no flop, crunchy crust, all in all a great slice.

Average, at best. Regular Slice looks like it was laying around all day. Not much flavor. Over cooked. Grandma slice is also average, at best. Doesn’t live up to the hype. Maybe if it were from a fresh pie, the slice would be better. Rated as is, though.