Willie's New York Style Pizza

I’ll definitely be back! It was a great experience and the owner was awesome!

Willie did not disappoint. We were there at 12:45pm on a Sunday - he said come back at 1pm. Asked him what a Stromboli was - he said it didn’t matter he doesn’t have it anyway. Asked for a large house salad and cheese pie - he said only pizza. Great Pie - Great, no an amazing experience. They don’t make guys like Willie anymore. Must try if close by.

Had to try this again after Dave’s review. Willie is still an a-hole, but funny. Made one customer drop his phone he was so rattled. Kinda douchey move playing the One bite review on the tv while he’s making pizza, but I think (hope) he’s just having fun with it. That said I think Dave’s spot on with this one. Very good pizza. Unique crust.

Willie was a true character and a joy to be around. The pizza was phenomenal!! I’d highly recommend going!! My brother and his wife said it was the best pizza they’d ever had and it’s from a gas station.

Unbelievable service and even better pizza.

Very tasty, non greasy slice. Could use a little more crisp but overall very good.

Hands down, definitely the best pizza in the area. Not sure what that guy John Kelly reviewed. He’s not basing his rating on the pizza, he just can’t handle the owner. Lol. The owner is a little rough around the edges, that’s what makes this place so intriguing. I love that he’s like the pizza Nazi. Classic. Just like his pizza and salads, classic and scrumptious.

Good stuff

Great pizza. Absolute best around. Willie is the man

Great to have a pizza made by the legendary Willie. The guy is working his ass off and cranking out great pizzas for over 44 years. Great crust with nice char and crunch. Slightly floppy but it’s fresh dough and we got toppings so that might add to the flop. Willie does it himself and just runs the show keeping everyone organized. Right up there with the best dough I’ve ever had. He is a true master at his craft and it was an honor to meet Willie!

I’ve tried about every pizza spot in the area and willie wins period.

Really good taste, not too floppy and again the taste is 🤤👌🏻

Great pizza but the experience is even better!

Amazing considering it's gas station pizza. It's excellent.

Amazing pizza and a great guy.

Loved the pizza! The green sauce on top was amazing.

Very good pizza

Pizza is trash, do not recommend and in no way does it represent NY pizza. They also won’t take order over the phone, which is insane, relax guys, your pizza place is in a gas station 😂

Great pizza! Great guy!

This place has the whole package! It’s not just great pizza but the experience is amazing