Xeno's Pizza - The Best Pizza Slices in Midtown East NYC

Pretty good slice !!!!!

Pizza Review: Solid Slice with Good Balance This pizza had a solid flavor, with a well-balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio that made each bite satisfying. The sauce had a nice tang without being overpowering, and the cheese was well-melted without feeling greasy. The crust was tasty—not too doughy, not too crispy, just a good bite that complemented the rest of the pie. While it wasn’t life-changing, it was definitely an enjoyable slice. Overall, I’d rate it a 6.9/10—a good option if you’re in the mood for a reliable pizza experience.

Well structured good reliable slice, not greasy, great service

This was a pretty good pizza. I had 4 slices of meat lovers(can’t remember what they call it) and the slices were pretty big so next time I’ll only need 3. I liked the crispy pizza dough, the sauce was decent and a decent quantity of meat..

Great taste great crust

Diamond in the rough spot. Super crispy and no flop. Crust could use a touch more flavor, but overall it’s got that classic NY taste and holds its consistency very well.

As rock solid as it gets. A little greasy but high 7s all around for the crunch, taste, undercarriage, and flop. Will be a returning customer

Great crisp and consistency, no flop. Fresh and hot NY slice with good undercarriage. Decent crust. Flavor profile is a tad muted, which is why you can’t go 8+, but it’s a very good spot for a slice.

What an amazing spot. It was great

Standard NYC slice

Plain is great, pepperoni was good with a nice spice, vodka margarita was good

Good ny pizza. No flop. Crust is very crunchy and cheese is good

Solid NY slice, no more, no less.

Great slice .. zero flop