The normal cheese pizza was amazing. Can really taste the quality of the sauce and cheese with a nice and slightly crispy crust. Very very good!
mark.denzin5/22/23, 6:25 p.m.
Great pizza and came here because I seen the review from el Presidente. Exactly what I wanted in a New York slice!
nate.scott5/7/23, 3:28 a.m.
Waited over an hour for this…Good sauce and great cheese. A little greasy. Crust is solid. Above average pie
chris.stone13/20/23, 3:03 a.m.
Prez was right. This pizza is in the sevens. Good overall. You can eat here regularly and be happy each time. Not in the eights because it’s not worth traveling for. If you’re in Scottsdale then it’s good and you’ll be happy.
shelby.stone3/20/23, 3:00 a.m.
Nice and crisp. Not greasy. Good crunch on the crust. Will definitely come back if I’m in the area.
doug.s12/26/23, 3:29 a.m.
The most incredible pie ever. The pic is just the slice about an hour old, but man, was it good. We went after seeing the Barstool review. This is my kind of pie. Thin and crispy with great sauce and not too much cheese. This is one of the top 3 pies of my life. I'm from New York. The owner is very cool... and humble. Thank u for a great pizza experience.
ethan.schleis2/11/23, 11:12 p.m.
Good amount of sauce, not a huge fan of the very pungent sauce flavor. Cheese is tasty. Crust is good, and crispy but rest of pizza is a bit soggy and has some flop. Undercarriage is just average. Good pizza, not great pizza. I expected more considering it’s often recommended.
kendall.j1/8/23, 12:15 a.m.
🍕One bite, everyone knows the rules. Great crust, good undercarriage, nice flop. Sauce and toppings, just ok. 7.1 🍕
jordan.kariniemi10/12/22, 2:41 a.m.
Excellent crisp, great taste, good sauce amount. Slightly greasy but overall pretty amazing
ryan.mcweeny5/23/22, 6:05 a.m.
I've had Sally's, I've had John's, I've had Joe's. Yo Pauly's goes toe to toe with all of em!
kevbike9/26/21, 3:22 a.m.
Best New York style slices I’ve had in Arizona. Nice ratios of sauce, cheese and crust. Solid crisp.
jamesjohnston8/17/21, 10:30 p.m.
Oh man. I wasn’t disappointed. Great pizza and even better customer service. I can’t wait to come back.
pizzaz88/5/21, 6:52 p.m.
I came to this places a week ago and had a couple slices. If I was to review those ones it would have been 7.6. These slices were a HUGE let down. Total flop and frigging COLD! There was a tone of grease as well. WTH?